Monday, October 31, 2005

Descending into Hell, Angels, Giants, the Sons of God & Daughters of Men

Genesis 6:1-4
1 Now it came about, when men began to multiply on the face of the land, and daughters were born to them, 2 that the sons of God saw that the daughters of men were beautiful; and they took wives for themselves, whomever they chose. 3 Then the LORD said, "My Spirit shall not strive with man forever, because he also is flesh; nevertheless his days shall be one hundred and twenty years." 4 The Nephilim were on the earth in those days, and also afterward, when the sons of God came in to the daughters of men, and they bore children to them. Those were the mighty men who were of old, men of renown. Then the LORD saw that the wickedness of man was great on the earth, and that every intent of the thoughts of his heart was only evil continually.

Genesis 6 tells us what occurred as mankind multiplied on the face of the Earth. Gen 5 tell us the generations of Adam and roughly 1056 years from the creation of Adam to the year of Noah's birth. (In that millennium, given the life span of individuals, it would not be a stretch to assume that even if each patriarch had a minimum of 10 children there would be millions of people on the Earth.) By the later days of Noah's life mankind had grown so corrupt that the "sons of God" took wives of the "daughters of men". This is an important acknowledgement. They took wives of "whomever they chose" even from the daughters of men. They didn't merely produce offspring with them, but actively cohabitated with them making them wives.

The Question
With this background we can approach the real question, what is the identity of the "sons of God" who took wives of the "daughters of men"?


Angelic Offspring Theory
Some believe that these "sons of God" were angelic beings who procreated with human women, producing an offspring of supernatural ability. Some even suggest that the reason for this was that Satan wanted to corrupt the race of mankind through the introduction of angelic seed. Verse 4 introduces to us the legendary Nephilim, of which the Bible says very little. The King James version translated Nephilim to "giants", the Hebrew word Nephilim apparently comes from the word for "fall". Some have believed this to be because men fell before them, or perhaps they were giants. Some, who view the "sons of God" as being fallen angels, view the Nephilim as supernaturally endowed strongmen and giants. This has led many to assume that the "sons of God" had to be more than mere humans. Those who hold this view point to the book of Job wherein the "sons of God" are described presenting themselves before God when Satan "also came among them." Job 38:7 indicates that these "sons of God" were present during creation as well thus it is reasonable to identify the "sons of God" (at least in the book of Job) as angels. This view is often imported then into other passages of the Bible, namely 1 Peter 3 in which we read:



1 Peter 3:18-21
18 For Christ also died for sins once for all, the just for the unjust, so that He might bring us to God, having been put to death in the flesh, but made alive in the spirit;19 in which also He went and made proclamation to the spirits now in prison, 20 who once were disobedient, when the patience of God kept waiting in the days of Noah, during the construction of the ark, in which a few, that is, eight persons, were brought safely through the water. 21 Corresponding to that, baptism now saves you--not the removal of dirt from the flesh, but an appeal to God for a good conscience--through the resurrection of Jesus Christ,



Some see the "spirits [now] in prison" who were disobedient "days of Noah" as identifying those same "sons of God". Thus, they believe, after Christ died he entered hell and made proclamation to these disobedient angels. Those who hold this view often point to Jude 1:6 "And angels who did not keep their own domain, but abandoned their proper abode, He has kept in eternal bonds under darkness for the judgment of the great day," Another iteration of this theory adopts the "Abraham's Bosom" (Luke 16:22-23) concept, believing that the dead of the Old Testament existed in a form of prison-like limbo, perhaps with these same angels. At Christ's death, it is believed, he went to hell (adopting the language of the Apostle's Creed) and preached to them there, saving those who would believe. Those who adopt this viewpoint then transfer this view into Ephesians 4 wherein it is written,



Eph 4:8-10
8 Therefore it says, "WHEN HE ASCENDED ON HIGH, HE LED CAPTIVE A HOST OF CAPTIVES, AND HE GAVE GIFTS TO MEN." 9 (Now this expression, "He ascended," what does it mean except that He also had descended into the lower parts of the earth? 10 He who descended is Himself also He who ascended far above all the heavens, so that He might fill all things.)



Believing that there were people in some limbo state, they believe this is referring to Christ taking them from prison to heaven. This is particularly true of dispensational viewpoints who cannot conceive of a salvation of grace gospel prior to the death of Christ.

Before offering an alternative theory, let me note that not everyone who adopts one or more of these concepts accepts all the others.

The Problem & Solution
As I mentioned earlier, some of these views come from aberrant beliefs such as extreme dispensationalism wherein the plan and purpose of the sovereign God is muddled with misinterpretations and false inferences. Not understanding that the Bible presents one plan of salvation for all men, they cannot conceive of a means for believing Old Testament saints to be ushered into Heaven apart from the temporal crucifixion. The Bible however presents one Gospel throughout the Old and New Testaments (which is in actuality an artificial division) though revealed partially in the Old and revealed fully in Christ.

One need only point to Galatians where we are told that Abraham heard and believed in the same Gospel which saves today. Gal 3:8 states that the gospel was preached "beforehand to Abraham, saying, " ALL THE NATIONS WILL BE BLESSED IN YOU."" Thus Paul writes, that it was evident that God would justify the Gentiles by faith (as Abraham was originally a Gentile) and "it is those who are of faith who are sons of Abraham." Thus Christ, the "lamb slain from the foundation of the world" (Rev 13:8, KJV), saved men and women who believed in the Gospel, no matter how veiled, since the beginning. Therefore we must understand that the salvation of men through has always been by faith in the Savior, be it the Savior to come or the Risen Savior, and this has been the only means of salvation in all of history. Paul states clearly that no one was saved by the Law since "by the works of the Law no flesh will be justified in His sight; for through the Law comes the knowledge of sin" and as the author of Hebrews informs us "it is impossible for the blood of bulls and goats to take away sins." With this understanding in mind, we can proceed to review the texts in question again.

The Alternative - Sons of God
First it must be noted While Gen 6:4 may seem to suggest that the Nephilim were the offspring of the "sons of God" and the "daughters of men", it doesn't actually state that, rather it only puts these two facts together in the same timeline. Even if the Nephilim were the offspring of said union, it doesn't mean they are giants, rather they could be kings or otherwise merciless men. The Nephilim are again referred to in Numbers 13:33, where the spies sent into the land of Canaan reported back that in Canaan lived the legendary Nephilim who are identified as the men of Anak. This is declared by Scripture to be a "bad report", however, given by men frightened by the task at hand. They say "all the people whom we saw in it are men of great size", this is of course not the case. Clarification comes in Deut 1:28 wherein we discover that the 'Nephilim', Anakim, reported in Num 13:33 were simply "bigger and taller" and from Deut 2:10 "numerous". We might consider these people like some consider those of Germanic offspring, naturally tall and muscular in build, but by no means supernatural giants. Calvin believed the Nephilim to be so called because men fell before them like wheat before storm winds, laying waste and bringing destruction. When the children of Israel finally take Canaan, actual giants are few and far between and not mentioned again until 1 Chronicles 20:1 where we meet the giants of Gath who certainly do fit our frightening picture of legendary giants. However, neither the brothers from Gath nor the Anakim can be actual Nephilim, who must have been destroyed in the Noahic flood. If the "Nephilim" be their offspring, then it is because they are ruthless unbelieving men striking fear in the hearts of their victims. As reasonable as it is to identify the "sons of God" as angels in Job, it is not as reasonable to import that connection into Genesis.

Consider that Psalm 82:6 declares "I said, "You are gods, and all of you are sons of the Most High." This verse, quoted by Christ, is addressing unjust human rulers, it is therefore just as acceptable (and as I hope to explain, more acceptable) that the term "sons of God" in Genesis refers to humans, rather than angels. Thus, along with many other respectable commentators, I suggest that the "sons of God" in this passage be those like Solomon, who while believers in the truth, took wives of pagans. Some have appealed to Gen 19:1-5 to show that angels can procreate, but the fact that the sinful men of Sodom desired to have sex with angels who appeared as men cannot lend any support to this view.

One commentator goes so far as to proclaim: "Only the obscene, perverse marriage of fallen angels with human females would seem to justify such a harsh judgment." But this is not the reason given by Scripture, rather it is the fact that "the wickedness of man was great on the earth, and that every intent of the thoughts of his heart was only evil continually" that causes God to obliterate and recreate the Earth. Finally the Bible indicates that angels are non-corporeal beings who cannot procreate. There is no discussion anywhere (other than this view of Gen 6) of angels procreating, yet the Bible does tell us that angels in heaven "neither marry nor are given in marriage". Believing otherwise brings up a whole host of problems relating to the potential DNA of angels, the ability of them to procreate with human women, and the possibility of it occurring again. The idea that Satan engineered these events to somehow pollute the bloodline of Christ is, in my opinion, without exegetical support once the verses in question are seriously examined.

1 Peter 3:18-21
This brings us to 1 Peter 3:18-21 where we must read the text with a different lens given our understanding of the universal historical proclamation of the Gospel. It was "in the Spirit" that Christ made the gospel proclamation to the spirits who are now in prison. The "spirits" are in prison now, that doesn't mean they were in prison when the proclamation was made. The proclamation was made "in the days of Noah, during the construction of the ark", and not after Christ's death in some form of limbo. Thus when we read that Noah was a "preacher of righteousness" (2 Pet 2:5) we must understand that Noah preached the Gospel, however veiled, which would save none-the-less if believed, as proven by the salvation of himself and his family from the flood. This is clear from the context of Peter's letters, especially the passage just mentioned (2 Pet 2:5). It was by the Spirit that Christ in Noah preached the Gospel to the unbelievers until only 8 were saved from the flood by the Ark. Peter makes mention of the flood and the ark and likens them to baptism in which we are cleansed just as the world was cleansed. (There is obviously much more to this point, which I'll save for a later date.) The "spirits" in this passage then are not angels but unbelieving individuals who rejected the Gospel then and are in now in prison. This then removes this passage from our consideration in determining who the "sons of God" are.

Ephesians 4
The "captives" Christ leads into heaven in Eph 4 then are not souls who were waiting in limbo for the crucifixion to occur, rather this language describes a conquering general who leads a train of captives away to his kingdom from a defeated city. Rather than receiving gifts from the Father (though we are considered His inheritance) Christ gives gifts to men. These captives then are the souls whom Christ won from the bondage of sin, leading them into heaven by His victory on the cross. Christ's "decent" into hell has been historically understood not as a physical appearance in some Dante-esque hell wherein he made proclamation to angels or Old Testament.

Jude 1:6
It is interesting the various verses and authors appealed to in order to support the angelic offspring belief. Jude 1:6 perhaps provides the best evidence, but it fails for lack of support. While it is true that Jude 1:6 describes fallen angels, it doesn't state that they procreated with men, rather that they "left their abode". This was all part of the plan and purpose of God.

Summary
The "sons of God" in Gen 6 are the believers and offspring of believers who wrongly marry unbelieving women. The Nephilim may be (though it is not a sure thing) the offspring of such unions, but the Nephilim are by no means supernatural giants but mere men. Nothing in Scripture suggests that angels can procreate, especially with human women. Genesis 6 then is an expression of the sinfulness of mankind, not angels, and the reason for God's destruction and recreation of the world both in the flood and in the apocalypse to come is due not to the sinfulness of angels, nor their supposed procreation with men, but solely on the basis of the corruption of human sin. 1 Peter 3:18-21 presents us with a picture of God's graciousness to the family of Noah who (as explained in 2 Peter) preached the Gospel to unbelievers by the Spirit of Christ within him.

Those who disobeyed and rejected Noah's plea are now in hell. Ephesians 4 speaks not of Christ's decent into Dante's inferno to declare to angels or Old Testament saints but rather of Christ's victorious ascent into heaven from Earth with a train of captives, namely the saints. Jude 1:6 does express the falleness of angels, but speaks nothing of their ability nor the possibility of their procreating with human women.

The views which I am rejecting here I believe present a corrupted anthropology and theology in regards to the nature of angels, men and God's sovereign plan. Whether taken together or apart, they all stem from misunderstandings of God's plan and historical revelation, be it dispensationalistic views of pre-crucifixion salvation or false teaching regarding angels and pre-flood sexual practices. I would go so far as to say that the angel/human procreation view stems not from Biblical exegesis but from post-Exodus Hebrew mythology especially found in the apocryphal works specifically the book called Jubilees and other rabbinic writings sometimes referred to as the Kenite doctrines. The end result of such views can alter a person's understanding of salvation, especially in a covenantal framework, and lead them to adopt other aberrant views. The beauty of the alternative view is that it harmonizes all of Scripture, not being informed by Jewish mythological texts, but rather accepting a God who is truly Sovereign over all that occurs in His created order, including the potential sexual practices of demons, and destroyed the Earth not on a whim or because the demons got out of hand, but as a striking example of His wrath, grace and prefiguring the work of His Son and the baptism of regeneration in which He saves us from our sins. Of this theory of angelic intercourse with humans, Calvin writes:



That ancient figment, concerning the intercourse of angels with women, is abundantly refuted by its own absurdity; and it is surprising that learned men should formerly have been fascinated by ravings so gross and prodigious. The opinion also of the Chaldean paraphrase is frigid; namely, that promiscuous marriages between the sons of nobles, and the daughters of plebeians, is condemned. Moses, then, does not distinguish the sons of God from the daughters of men, because they were of dissimilar nature, or of different origin; but because they were the sons of God by adoption, whom he had set apart for himself; while the rest remained in their original condition. Should any one object, that they who had shamefully departed from the faith, and the obedience which God required, were unworthy to be accounted the sons of God; the answer is easy, that the honor is not ascribed to them, but to the grace of God, which had hitherto been conspicuous in their families. For when Scripture speaks of the sons of God, sometimes it has respect to eternal election, which extends only to the lawful heirs; sometimes to external vocations according to which many wolves are within the fold; and thought in fact, they are strangers, yet they obtain the name of sons, until the Lord shall disown them. Yea, even by giving them a title so honorable, Moses reproves their ingratitude, because, leaving their heavenly Father, they prostituted themselves as deserters. - John Calvin, Commentary on Genesis, Volume I, Baker 1996, Trans: Rev John King



I look forward to your comments.

Friday, October 28, 2005

"Instant Heaven"

A short time after 9/11 I saw John MacArthur on Larry King Live stating that every child who died in the 9/11 attacks obtained "instant heaven". Later I heard a sermon he gave and read some materials of his relating to this topic.

Today then I read a blog post by centuri0n about which some users commented and mentioned this topic again. I started to reply in his blog, but realized there's too much to say for such a forum, so I'm bringing it here.

Both
John MacArthur and R. Albert Mohler Jr. (along with Daniel Akin of SBTS), hold to the view that all those who die in infancy automatically go to heaven. Many of my good friends also hold this view.
I firmly believe that the Bible is SILENT on, not merely "quiet", but actually silent on this issue.
I may perhaps take time to further flesh out this discussion later, but I wanted to make some general comments tonight. (It's really late!)

Firstly, the meaning of the verse wherein
David laments the death of his son and says "I will go to him" (2 Sam 12:23) is disputable and does not have mean "my son is in heaven and when I die I'll be there too". David's mention in the previous verse of God's graciousness is directed specifically at the possibility of having another child, not in reference to his reuniting with his deceased child in heaven. It is therefore more likely that David is referring to the grave as he is by no means rejoicing in this verse. I would say that this verse is similar to that modern saying "it is not right for someone to outlive their child". Often in Scripture it is mentioned that so-and-so was buried "with their fathers", yet here David is noting that the opposite will occur, he will be buried with his son. Yet, regardless of how one views this verse, there is nothing in this verse to give any kind of hope to the unbeliever that their child is in heaven!

Another passage referred to in support of this universalist paedo-salvation view is
Mar 10:14 and Luke 18:16, wherein Christ says "Permit the children to come to Me, and do not hinder them, for the kingdom of God belongs to such as these." Clearly, there is again nothing here to give the unbeliever hope that their child has defacto salvation until reaching the mythical age of accountability. Keep in mind that this very same passage is used by paedobaptists to support a completely different theological point all together, that is that children are covenant members and should be baptized. I don't believe either view can be substantiated by this passage but rather this verse is speaking to the heart of individuals who desire to see the Savior, children and adults alike, thus it states "the kingdom of God belongs to such as these." In the very next verse Christ says, "whoever does not receive the kingdom of God like a child will not enter it at all." Christ's point is not that all who die in infancy obtain "instant heaven" rather, that citizenship in the kingdom of God is based on child-like faith.

In his article, Dr.
Mohler first declares that all who are born of flesh are "marked with original sin" and that none are "born in a state of innocence", but later he states that because "these young children are incapable of committing sins in the body..." they "die secure in the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ". While Dr. Mohler does say "Christ has removed the stain of original sin from those who die in infancy", but what is his basis for this claim? It seems that because these children are "incapable of committing sins in the body" that Christ "removed the stain of original sin", but what Biblical support does Dr. Mohler provide for this? Mohler turns to Deut 1:35-39.
He states, (on the basis of Deut 1:39):
"The key issue here is that God specifically exempted from the judgment those who "have no knowledge of good or evil" because of their age... We believe that this passage bears directly on the issue of infant salvation, and that the accomplished work of Christ has removed the stain of original sin from those who die in infancy"
Yet God's declaration that the children "have no knowledge of good or evil" is not the reason for His sparing them from the judgment. That is, it is not because the children have some general "innocence" that they're spared, rather it is because these young ones (not simply infants) were not guilty of this particular sin that God graciously keeps His promise He made to their forefathers and spares them. Why do I say this? Consider that God surely knew that the children of the sinning Israelites would none-the-less likewise sin yet He spares them graciously.

The JFB commentary states about this passage: "...who know not as yet good or evil." As the children had not been partakers of the sinful outbreak, they were spared to obtain the privilege which their unbelieving parents had forfeited. God’s ways are not as man’s ways"
Again does this verse really have to do with all infants obtaining eternal salvation? One could just as easily point to the fate that befell Sodom or any of the other cities in which God's wrath was so clearly displayed against adult and infant alike and declare just the opposite of Mohler's position.

Mohler goes on, "The imputation of Adam’s sin and guilt explains our inability to respond to God without regeneration, but the Bible does not teach that we will answer for Adam’s sin."

Mohler seems to limit the extent of original sin so as to have it affect the will, but not actually trasnfer guilt. But this is not what the Bible presents. Romans 5 and elsewhere clearly express that "in Adam all die", we who call ourselves Reformed acknowledge that this is spiritual death, but apart from being made "alive in Christ" there is no solution to spiritual death and its result is condemnation unto damnation. Unless one is graciously transferred from the headship of Adam into the headship of Christ, they will die... not just die physically, but they will face the second death. This is what the doctrine of imputation is about, Adam's sin imputed to me (as well as my own sins being put in my acct) because Adam was my federal head. Likewise Christ's obedience and death is credited to me, apart from my own actions, and His resurrection secures my justification resulting in salvation. If Adam's sin doesn't make me guilty, on what basis can I be declared righteous in the sight of God on the basis of Christ's obedience in my stead? Imputation must work both ways, or its not imputation... if we want to seriously believe in the righteousness of Christ imputed to the believer, we must also believe in the sinfulness of Adam imputed to the unbeliever.

While
I agree that each "will answer "according to what he has done," it is also written that "death reigned from Adam until Moses, even over those who had not sinned in the likeness of the offense of Adam." Thus Adam's transgression was working already in his seed, condemning them regardless of their own actions. As one who has debated Pelagians of various stripes, I know that the doctrine of original sin and imputation are their primary targets and this misunderstanding of their nature plays right into the hands of the Pelagian apologist.

Yes, o
ne can and should make inferences from these various verses and say with certainty that the Bible supports the gracious salvation of some infants, but to make a blanket statement as John MacArthur did during a Larry King broadcast in stating that the children who died in the 9/11 attacks obtained "instant heaven" based on this filamentary and disputable evidence is irresponsible.

It seems there is a pastoral desire for many in caring for their flock and to comfort the emotional concerns of even unbelievers who consider the wrath of God somehow unjust when directed toward "innocent" infants. The fact of the matter is that Adam sinned in my stead, just as Christ obeyed in my stead. I am born a child of Adam but I am graciously made into a child of God by grace through faith. Declaring another means of universal salvation apart from the normative means expressed in Scripture flies in the face of what we who claim Sola Scriptura stand for.

There are proper times for the teacher of Scripture to acknowledge that there are some things that we simply don't know for certain. This is truly the only valid response to "what happens to infants who die". Yes you can discuss the various ideas, verses and such involved, give comfort to the grieving and such, but ultimately we must rely on our gracious God to do what is right in His eyes and not seek to speak out of place and put ourselves in judgement of the Almighty by telling Him what we would do in His place.

Thursday, October 20, 2005

HTPC

Was reading javajane's blog about BitTorrent and thought I might comment. While BitTorrent works fine for what it is there always seemed like a lot of steps to go thru and there were so many caveats along the way, the spyware/adware at nefarious websites and the like.
 
But there has been and will continue to be postings of films, music, television shows, and everything else under the sun in the Usenet newsgroups. Not that I advocate downloading copyrighted films etc, however...
 
Forgot to tape/DVR last night's LOST episode? alt.binaries.multimedia probably has it. With a cable internet connection that puppy can be yours in less than an hour*. Now... how to watch it.
 
What? Don't have a multimedia PC hooked up to your TV? Stop and consider an HTPC (Home Theater PC) for a moment. For about $600 you can have a PC (rather than that set-top DVR you keep paying for) that records TV, pauses TV and does all that stuff the DVR does, but also browses the web, allows you to listen to streaming audio (Generation 80s naturally..) and even play games on that gigantic screen you've got wasting away in the other room while you mess about on your PC.  One could also download HDTV quality versions of their favorite shows* for when they get that awesome 60" HD plasma.
 
*keep in mind, however, all of this is still illegal, best just to put the PC together yourself, get HDTV quality cable and record the shows.
 
I've got an AMD 2100+xp, 512meg RAM, Radeon 7000, with a Happauge WinTV card, running Windows XP Professional and it's recording shows for later viewing. My wife loves to watch Rachael Ray's cooking shows and even... the Brady Bunch.
 
Here's some links for those interested.
 
 
PCAlchemy - the source for HTPC

Wednesday, October 19, 2005

Generation 80s ~ Live365

There's a great music feed available for us products of the 1980s. I was checking out some iTunes radio feeds when I came upon this innocuous looking little station called Generations 80s Radio. Well, after having blasted my ears out with some very crude "comedy" I was looking for something I could work with and enjoy listening to. To my surprise, rather than the usual pop-hits type collection the first thing I heard was New Order followed soon after by The Sisters of Mercy... needless to say, I'm in radio-love!
The owner of said station, Java Jane, has a pretty cool blog too, I highly recommend both the station and the blog. Psssst... btw, she's also partial to the 'cause'.
Sola Fide ladies and gents!

Tuesday, October 4, 2005

Phil R. Johnson, the theonomist

Phil Johnson, John MacArthur's right-hand man, has an interesting blog post on 'Christian Pacifists' and makes the following remark:
Several years ago, at the church I was attending at the time, we had a kind and godly deacon who had served as a counselor in our church for many years. He was also a city cop.Sometimes church discipline has to be done the hard way."
Is Phil Johnson promoting small-t theonomy? :-D

Thursday, September 15, 2005

Sex Slaves in Islam

Now that I have your attention.
 
Reading some articles on Islam I came across the following:
"I asked the Shaykh, what was the ruling on slaves, and whether it was permitted for a male master to sleep with slave women against their will. He simply said yes. I asked to clarify, so if there was a slave market today, I could go and buy a fourteen year old girl just in order to sleep with her? He said yes, and he added, not only was it permitted, it was also common practice among early Muslims. Ali Ibn Abi Talib, the shaykh said, had children from his slaves."  Oliver Ruebenacker, MuslimWakeUp! 2005 
Two questions... first, this is the same religion "of peace" we keep hearing promoted in the media? Secondly, how different is this from what occured to Hagar in Genesis?

Tuesday, September 13, 2005

No Silver Bullets

Bang!It has come to my attention over the past few weeks that many Christians who engage with others of different faiths, first come to apologetics looking for the 'Silver Bullet' (and I don't mean cheap beer), the quest for the one perfect apologetic answer that will demolish the opponent's case.

I've been recently speaking with my sister, who lives in Florida, about apologetic issues. She mentioned that she was bringing up specific problems within a cult to her cultic friends. She seemed to be wanting specific things that would nail the lid on the proverbial coffin. As one example of my sister's attempts at finding this bullet, was to quote a fellow who, in supposedly describing the main problem with Roman Catholicism, explained that the doctrine of Immaculate Conception logically led to a Jesus who was not "like his brothers" in all ways. This 'apologist', believing that because Christ was born to a woman who was graced before her birth he was somehow "not human." Thus, she proclaimed, this was an excellent argument against Roman Catholicism...

I attempted to explain that we even non-Roman Catholics believe that Christ was born sinless, though not due to some supposed pre-partum grace to His mother. Thus this belief that Christ being born without sin was not somehow unorthodox but part of the historic Christian faith. Also, approaching a Roman Catholic with this 'apologetic' would lead nowhere since it is basically a strawman and doesn't touch on the real issues needing addressing.

I explained that Roman Catholics do not deny that Christ came "in the flesh" and that this kind of argumentation shows a gross misunderstanding of the fundamental issues that divide Protestants and Roman Catholics. When she asked me what I thought the main issues diving Roman Catholics and Protestants was, she seemed surprised to learn that I believed justification by faith alone and not the nature of Christ to be the number one issue.

While at the Alpha & Omega Ministries conference in Seattle, I spoke with a woman who came to the book table looking for books and recordings likewise providing her with the means to address specific concepts within certain cults. She was asking "does this address (insert belief here)", and I could only reply (since I've not listened to all the recordings, "I'm not sure." I then directed her to Dr. James White's Theology and Apologetics Seminar CDs and to Greg Bahnsen's book Always Ready (which I'm currently reading) to little avail, unless it provided her with the one sure-thing in apologetics weaponry she wasn't too interested.

During the past few years I too went looking for this proverbial silver bullet. Often I'd think "Ah ha! That's it!" only to find that it was neither relevant nor absolute. Nailing-jello-to-the-wall not withstanding, many evidentialistic arguments cannot address the world-view of the individual's system. Sometimes my argument would even lead to a compromise of my own position... much like my sister's argument. (If Christ was not sinless, how could he pay for my sins!?)

What I'm coming to realize is that apologetics is not about demolishing a single argument, or addressing one particular claim, but understanding and addressing the cultic system of belief.

I recently took an Apologetics class with Pastor Charles McIlheney, pastor of San Francisco Orthodox Presbyterian Church. This was a study of Christian Apologetics by Van Til and it opened my eyes to the realm of discussion that lay beyond surface level argumentation. I'm now reading Bahnsen's aforementioned book and hope to gain more insight into addressing one's system of belief.

Finally, I've engaged in a email discussion with the father of a good friend of mine. Both he and his son are involved in the idea of Universal Redemption. Based on the writings of A.E. Knoch and a translation called the "Concordant Literal", they're of Arian stripe. Our initial discussion has been on the deity of Christ, but I'm wondering if something even more basic isn't in order... In reviewing the letter to the Ephesians and its continual exposition on the Trinitarian nature of salvation, I began to wonder how my friend and his father can be part of a 'Christian church' while not following the words of Paul in that letter. God has gifted us, (I paraphrase Paul here), to specific tasks and abilities within the church to the edification of the body.

How can one be a Christian and attempt to defend the Christian faith while not belonging to a body of believers, being submitted to an overseer or elder, hearing the reading of the Word and partaking of the (gasp) Sacraments? Surely the deity of Christ is very, very, important, but what is a Christian without the church?

More to come... I'm sure!

Radio.Blog Update


I  realize its been a long time since I updated my Radio.Blog. Inspired by my sister in Christ, Julie, I've updated it with some soundtracks and a couple timeless classics.
1. Vespertilio - From the Batman Begins soundtrack. Intense, building themes from my favorite film composer Hans Zimmer and James Newton Howard. The titles of the tracks on this score are the Latin names of different species of bat.
 
2. Molossus - Again from the Batman Begins soundtrack, this is the car chase, if I recall correctly. I've been working out to this lately.
 
3. Stories for a Thousand Years - Hans Zimmer in a piece for a PBS TV show called Millennium.
 
4. Main Title - Dune - Toto - Yes, THE BAND Toto you remember from the 80s. They did an awesome job for the soundtrack to the David Lynch film Dune, based on the book by Frank Herbert. Love the film or hate it, this soundtrack rocks.
 
5. Take My Hand - Dune - Toto - The final selection from this great score. This song has a lot of personal meaning for me, and its a very emotional thing to listen to.
 
6. Television - Ring 2 - End Titles from the sequel to the legendary scary movie. I've not seen either film, but again Hans Zimmer... I love this guy.
 
7. ... can you guess?  - This is a piece composed by David Arnold, a British composer. This is a piece from his second soundtrack from a 1990s Sci-Fi film. This is the End Titles from the film.
 
8. In-a-gadda-da-vida - Iron Butterfly - This was artfully used in the TV film Manhunter, based on the Thomas Harris novel Red Dragon. This was later made into a more recent film. The original however was directed by Michael Mann of Miami Vice fame, in 1986. Mann has come to be a favorite director of mine, along with Ridley Scott, who have a very unique style to their direction. Mann seems to have been infected with neon during his Miami Vice days, I recently saw the film Heat starring Robert DiNero and Al Pacino and again noticed the starkness of Mann's direction. Needless to say, this song, by Iron Butterfly, has a whole lore of its own...
 
9. Blue Sky Mine - Midnight Oil -from the album Blue Sky Mine - These last two selections are not used in any films to my knowledge, however they've been influential to me both by the Aussie band known affectionately as the "Oils". First is Blue Sky Mine, this song was my introduction to the Oils back in the late 80s. Little did I know there was a huge collection of fantastic work by them previously. I've seen the Oils in concert a couple of times, prior to Peter Garrett's leaving (the lead singer). Both in concert and recorded, the Oils were a force to be reckoned with. I often find myself belting these songs out at the top of my lungs whenever I hear them played.
 
10. Dead Heart - Midnight Oil - While I don't specifically agree with what's said in this song, one cannot help but sing it none-the-less. Garrett, the former lead singer of the band, was always politically active in his home nation of Australia, he's since left the band to be come a member of the Austrailian Parliament. The bald giant was an impressive sight on the concert stage... nothing quite prepares> you for the erratic motions of the man.

That's it for now. I'm sure there will be more to come in the future. I've got some stuff to say about this and about that, but as it is late... goodnight and good listening.

Tuesday, August 23, 2005

Gay Parents / Strangers & Custody Rights

Aside from the acceptance of a perverse lifestyle as normal and the granting of custody of children to those who promote and engage in perversion, the recent court rulings on 'equal protection' for homosexuals opens a gaping hole in the structure of the family. Not simply in a moralistic conceptual way, but in a tangible way that will undoubtedly show itself soon.

The Mercury News writes: "The rulings strengthened the custody rights of non-biological parents in same-sex unions and clarified the uncertain legal landscape for thousands of gay couples across California who decide to have children." What the rulings actually do is to grant the possibility of custody rights to individuals who have no legal marital or even domestic-partner connection to the children. Again from the Mercury News:

"Now, the high court has extended that principle to custody feuds like one unfolding in Santa Clara County for Linda Hulberg, a Morgan Hill woman who has been seeking parental rights for two years from her former partner. Hulberg was in a three-year relationship with a woman who bore twin boys, and acted as a co-parent until their 2003 breakup, according to court papers." (Gay parents gain key custody rights, Howard Mintz, San Jose Mercury News, Aug. 23, 2005)

Consider what's being said here: a woman who was friends with another woman for three years and acted as a "co-parent" during those three years can have access and even custody of the woman's biological children. The article of course quotes the 'conservative' viewpoint as: "By saying that children can have two moms, the court has undermined the family." While true, it misses the larger picture that basically anyone who has lived in one's house or even occasionally taken care of another's children can have potential custody rights of those children. Consider the implications...

Can the teenage babysitter who has come to one's home for the past five years, thus acting as a 'co-parent' (definition questionable of course), claim custody rights after her/his termination? Can the nanny who has fed, watched over and taken care of one's children claim custody rights over them? If a three-year relationship without any legal status can grant one rights to custody over one's kids, how can the state, who feeds, teaches, cares for and raises one's children, five days a week, for more than a decade through the public school system not qualify for custody?

Another ruling "gives gay partners the same protections as married couples in terms of how they are treated by businesses." This will of course play into the state's anti-discrimination policies and thus again put pressure on churches and businesses that believe homosexuality to be perversion and incompatible with employment...

Thursday, August 11, 2005

Email as a blogging tool...

For those who use Blogger as their blogging system, I highly recommend using Outlook or some other HTML-capable email system to blog. Aside from being easy as sending an email, it also makes placing images and the like a breeze. To enable this feature in Blogger, go to Blogger and log-in, then go to the Settings tab and select "Email", choose a "mail-to-blogger address" and then start blogging!
Bloggin!
This post and the previous one were both done in this manner.

Konfabulator

A while ago I downloaded this program called "Konfabulator" which promised to add some of the functionality of the Mac OS to Windows XP. The program was not free, at the time, and there weren't man 'widgets' (the mini-aps built for Konfabulator) that interested me.

Variety of WidgetsThings have changed. Konfabulator was bought recently by Yahoo! and now version 2 is free, plus there are many wonderful widgets available.

To the left is an example of my current desktop with various widgets. You can see a calendar widget, weather, miniMail, system monitors etc.

The one caveat to these cool aps is... they all use memory and each one shows up as "konfabulator.exe" in your task manager. This makes it hard to determine which to close if one is acting wonky.

Other than that, they don't take up a lot of memory, and are quite useful and attractive.

Tuesday, August 9, 2005


Micah as a Lego
Here's a cool link to the 'minimizer' which you can use to define your self as a lego person.

Now, as to my prolonged absence from the IRC world... I'm on a forced break because of misuse. Don't be like me!

Friday, July 1, 2005

Book Tag
I've been tagged by my bro and sis at Theomony so here goes:

1. How many books do you own?

Hundreds... mostly theology,
sci-fi, travel or dog-care books. That said, many of my books have been thoroughly tasted by Max. He has in fact eaten through parts of Charles Hodge's Systematic Theology third volume as well as my old NASB and even some Doug Wilson books. (Good dog! ;) ) I try and trade my old books in for credit at a local used book store.


2. What was the last book you bought?
I was given a copy of The ShadowFox Chronicles by the author, Julie Staples, as to what book I last bought... that would probably have been Christian Apologetics by Cornelius Van Til, along with The Calvinistic Concept of Culture by Cornelius' nephew Henry Van Til. I've not read much of the second book.




3. What was the last book you read?
Christian Apologetics by Cornelius Van Til.
Currently reading
The ShadowFox Chronicles
.







4. What are some books that meant a lot to you?

Commentary on Galatians - Martin Luther
Luther's exposition of the Gospel vs Legalism is still the standard, no matter what my FV friends say.




Starship Troopers - Robert Heinlein
Prior to reading this novel I was interested in Japanese animation, especially of the giant robot type. Heinlein's classic seems to have been the inspiration for much of that, especially the older Gundam series. I've owned a copy of this book since I first read it.



Ender's Game - Orson Scott Card
The little guy does good... sort of. Classic Sci-Fi book by the Mormon author, Card. The other books in this series were not as good (in my opinion.)

Movie due out 2006?



Rabbit (? not sure) - not sure of author
When I was a child, my favorite book was this wordless book about a rabbit and a carrot. I've dreamt of the images in that book and yet cannot remember the title or author.

5. Tag! You're It:SpideyGeek

Wednesday, June 29, 2005


I'm a nobody. It seems that at least a few times every quarter I have to remind myself of this fact. I'm a lazy, uneducated, gluttonous nobody. I don't say this to make you feel sorry for me or to gain sympathy, but simply to recognize and acknowledge that the depression and anger I sometimes feel when I cannot grasp, do not agree, or feel inadequate in something is a direct result of my failure to do more than I have.

I could put more effort into everything I do, but I just don't. So when I discuss something with someone and they don't understand or agree with my point of view, the anxiety and anger I feel is really uncalled for. The fact of the matter is that I'm honestly not nearly as intelligent as I think I am, or believe I am.

I often wonder then why I am interested in the things I am, and desire to engage others in those things. I've often thought of the disabled kid I knew in high school who was thrilled just to be able to tell anyone who'd listen what day it was. With more excitement than most can muster for their favorite subjects, this kid would exclaim "It's Wednesday!" How blissful it must be to know exactly what day it is and not care about what you do, or do not know.

More on this later... I've got to get back to getting things done.

Saturday, June 25, 2005

I made the switch




After working with Maxthon as an Internet Explorer replacement (which it isn't, its merely a shell for IE) I found more and more pop-ups being able to get around the Maxthon blocker and the Internet Explorer problems were still inherent in the system. I spent over 6 hours last week removing the latest version of CoolWebSearch and its cohorts from a coworker's PC which got installed because of the way Internet Explorer deals with pop-ups and exe installs. I've been a long time hold out for IE, but I've had it. I've switched to Firefox.

I'll report back and let you know what I think about Mozilla/Firefox.

As for spyware and the like, I've found a new (though commercial) application which did a very good job of removing the problems on that coworker's PC and I therefore now recommend Spyware Sweeper. It came with a free trial, which actually removed the spyware and found more than AdAware and others combined. I still recommend HijackThis for basic investigation, but Spyware Sweeper did a fine job. Be very careful installing any other 'spyware removing' software, as some are designed by spyware publishers themselves.

Friday, June 24, 2005

In Reply to Issues Etc. Article
"The Spirit Blows Even at Harvard" - by Brent McGuire

I wish to take issue with Brent McGuire's article in the Vol.4, No.2 issue of your journal. As a Reformed Baptist I find that the Issues Etc. radio program and journal are excellent resources for defending the faith and I find an article of this sort to be wholly uncharitable toward fellow citizens of God's Kingdom because of its misrepresentation of Baptists.

Firstly, Mr. McGuire seems intent on maligning Baptists in the eyes of readers by poisoning the well toward Baptists in general. He does this by attributing to them the beliefs and actions of former President Clinton and mixing beliefs of various denominations to paint the worst possible picture. While McGuire may have been quoting a Newsweek article in regards to Clinton, it would behoove him to rebut that article rather than quote on the basis of what Baptists truly believe and not support the mischaracterization therein.

This brings us to my second point, Mr. McGuire presents several, even contradictory, beliefs held by different branches of what has come to be called the 'Baptist' denomination, thus painting a truly dreadful picture of Baptists without regard to the truth of what we actually believe simply by using the word "many".

Would it be proper for me to write an article about Lutherans condemning them on the basis of what the ECLA holds to or to what groups such as 'herchurch.org' believe? Surely it would be dishonest and disrespectful for me to toss out such accusations and condemn Issues Etc. on the basis that "many Lutherans believe in worshipping the goddess". You can't trust that Todd Wilken... he's one of them.

So-called "Reformed" Baptists or Calvinistic Baptists, who indeed hold to the seemingly dreadful doctrines misrepresented in the latter half of the first portion (Limited atonement and Sovereign predestination), would deny the "once saved always saved" irresponsibility of those who hold to a "once saved always saved" position. Likewise, those who hold to said belief would certainly deny the Calvinistic distinctive of the others.

It find it also irresponsible of Mr. McGuire to attempt to explain the Reformed doctrine of predestination in two sentences without any explanation of the concepts therein and then attempt to lump all the aforementioned 'Baptists' into the same camp. Finally, most Calvinistic Baptists reject the 'age of accountability' as well as the aforementioned concept of 'OSAS', and do see the sacraments as being means of grace similar to other Reformed. The 1689 London Confession states:

Q. 98. How do Baptism and the Lord's Supper become effectual means of salvation?
A. Baptism and the Lord's Supper become effectual means of salvation, not from any virtue in them or in him that administers them, but only by the blessing of Christ and the working of His Spirit in them that by faith receive them. (1 Peter 3:21; 1 Cor. 3:6,7; 1 Cor. 12:13)


It is quite sad to see such a wonderful article (positively quoting many non-Lutherans such as Michael Horton) followed by this attempt to scandalize other Christians in such a demeaning manner. It seems Mr. McGuire is following the current trend of those who convert to another theological position in caustically misrepresenting those of his former belief. These are the tactics of our enemies, not fellow Christians.

Micah Burke

Thursday, April 14, 2005

For those who use MS Messenger, there's a great application that extends the usefulness of the ap called "Messenger Plus!"



One caveat... when installing make sure that you DO NOT install the sponsor application.

Wednesday, April 6, 2005

Not Flattered by Cheap Imitation

I work as a graphic designer for a mattress and sleep products retailer in Northern California. Recently I've noticed my designs turning up in other companies ads, both competitors and non-competitors. We recently sent a "Cease and Desist" order to one... then, today I found the following in the Fremont, California yellow pages:



This design is nearly identical to my yellow pages designs of 2002~2003:



I recently sent a letter to the editor of Home Furnishings Retailer magazine after reading a peice in which one of their editors encouraged retailers to 'search through magazines and newspapers, find an ad you like...' ""Tear it out! Hand it to your advertising director and say, "Copy this." Don't worry, you won't get sued because "pride of authorship" will keep you ad director from copying it exactly."

Now, as a designer, I use other people's material to get ideas, but where is this "pride of authorship" they spoke of?

Friday, March 11, 2005

Lucretia Beth (April) Shepphard

God answers prayer.

April Shepherd & Herb ShattuckAfter many years of battling rheumatoid arthritis, my dear friend April died this morning, March 11th. Of late, April had been staying at a convalescent home and had been steadily declining in health. She had advanced rheumatoid arthritis and her body was badly distorted as her joints had grown well beyond their normal positions. While her body was useless, she was still a beautiful lady and still had a sharp wit and demanding temperment. April had been mostly bed-ridden, except when someone dressed her and helped her out of bed, which was a difficult process at best. All of us who knew her had to help in some way. I'm sure few of us can imagine the frustration of having one's mind intact but unable to affect the world around us through movement.

April had been part of the 'Word of Faith' movement prior to the onset of the arthritis. Apparently she was even a 'pastor' of sorts at one time. Of course when the disease began to progress through her body, her faith was shaken to its core and her friends and church abandoned her because she didn't have "enough faith" to overcome the disease. She left that apostasy and began attending more traditional evangelical churches.

I met April several years ago in a Bible study of Romans taught by my friend and mentor Herb Shattuck. In a sense, we became 'Reformed' together. When the study moved from the church we began meeting in her home, since she couldn't reasonably go out. I was the youngest guy there, so it was up to me to move her from the wheel-chair to the couch where she'd listen, interject and sometimes sleep through our years of study together. Later, when I taught a class in Ephesians at her home she challenged the Catholic woman who was there to trust in Christ alone.

While April wasn't a saint, in her younger years and had made some terrible choices in her life, she became a sister in the Lord to me. And though her body was repulsive I found that I cared very much for her. She was still a tough cookie, however, and knew what she wanted, when she wanted it and exactly where she wanted it. She could be quite demanding, and I think that's plus her physical shape were some of the reasons some people found it hard to deal with her. For some, just the visual effect of her body was nearly impossible to handle. I believe that God gave me grace to handle it to some extent, but it was never easy.

Through our day-to-day lives as able-bodied persons it is easy to get so busy as to forget those who are 'physically-challenged' in such a way. I was always cut to the quick when I heard of some plight of April's. When living at her own hom, she once rolled nearly off of her bed and waited hours for someone to help her up. The eyesight goes and the ability read can also be lost. She usually couldn't change the radio station, tv channel or hit the VCR switches. We tried all sorts of mechanical gadgets to help, her son even sent her a voice-activated remote (which would have worked great, but by that time her voice was barely above a whisper.) She told me once that she'd listened to the same song over and over because the remote was out of reach. We take so much for granted.

April loved the Lord. She told everyone about Jesus, especially the kids who came at Halloween and the people who came to drive her around and take care of her. She and I would joust over points of doctrine, and yet she would get teary eyed at the thought of seeing the Lord face-to-face or thinking about those who are lost.

In her last days, April's body finally began to succumb to the disease. Rheumatoid arthritis is a token example of the results of the fall. The disease causes one's own body to attack itself and the growths and crumpled form that result can be terribly painful. In the end the body cannot properly process food, and the arteries and veins can loose the ability to properly transport blood. In essence, death wins.

April is with her Savior now. And while I am left to grieve for my sweet sister in the Lord, I can truly say that "she is in a better place". And while death had victory over her in this life, I know Christ has conquered death and that we'll be together at the wedding feast.

The last time I saw her, she was semi-conscious. She'd been on morphine for days and hadn't eaten much. Her son had flown in from back East in to take care of her, he questioned what he had to do, be it put to in a feeding tube or allow her to go back on the morphine... he went back home yesterday, and she was gone this morning.

I don't know all the lessons being with April taught us... for myself, my wife and April's other friends. I've learned to love and care for someone who was very difficult to care for. I pray that God will graciously extend that in my life, that I might treat others similarly. I'd very thankful for people like Don and Elenor, mutual friends of ours (and fellow Reformed Baptists) who would see her every few days and help her as much as they could, even being advanced in age themselves. I hope that I can emulate their attitude toward service of others.

The last time I saw her I prayed that God would make her better enough that she could eat and that we could talk together again... or that God would receive her into His kingdom quickly. I'm thankful, for her, that He chose the latter.

Please pray for her family, especially grace for her son, as they consider the life and death of April and that they might come to faith in the same Savior who was her only hope.

Obituary

Monday, February 21, 2005

Radio.Blog
Here's a neat thingy... I've been listening to 'radio.blogs' for a while and decided to make one of some of the tunes I'm fond of lately. I'll maybe ad more as time goes by. I recommend starting with "Dazzle" by Souixsie and the Banshees. (See right)

Also, here's an image of what it looks like nearby (relatively) in Bezerkeley...

Click for closeup.

Wednesday, January 12, 2005

ritzcamera.com and Ritz Camera are "two different companies"...
(and ritzcam.com another all together!)

Ok, I realize this isn't my usual theological post, but I have to rant about my experience.

I bought a Nikon D70 from Ritz Camera in San Francisco. Now I realize that Ritz isn't called "ritz" for nothing. They were more expensive than other vendors, but I was able to get the 0% financing deal through them and my wife was thrilled at the idea. So, I'm the happy owner of the coolest digital camera around. Then, for Christmas, my dear in-laws gave me a $100(!!!) gift card for Ritz Camera.

So off I went to ritzcamera.com to find something of interest to spend my money on. After much deliberations and discussions with another camera-owning pal, I settled on a Sigma 50mm f2.8 Macro lens. After popping it into my 'shopping cart' off I went to use the card. The website wouldn't take the card. So I called their support line. Their reply: "The card doesn't work at their "online store" as it was bought in a brick and mortar store, they're "two different companies"."

Now, keep in mind that ritzcamera.com has a "Store Locator" that directs you to the nearest Ritz Camera brick and mortar store. For "two different companies" they sure are friendly toward each other. Needless to say I was unable to get them to take my card, I did express my displeasure on the phone and in an email to their corporate site. I'll have to find a nearby superstore and spend my card there (including taxes and ordering costs no doubt.)

Finally... and this is an aside, there is also "ritzcam.com" which is not related to ritzcamera.com or Ritz Camera but is a (legitimate) seperate company in Phoenix, AZ and sells used camera collectables, and where I will probably spend more money. I do recommend these guys as they seem to know their stuff and have some good deals on used equipment.

Friday, September 17, 2004

Atonement & Justification - Type & Shadow


I recently had a conversation with a Lutheran friend regarding the Calvinist doctrine of Limited Atonement. Many of you know that I am quite partial toward our Lutheran brethren, seeing that their founder was an excellent exegete and had a most concise view of the Law/Gospel distinction. I find that there is much in the Lutheran (LCMS) tradition that interests me. There is, however, a few disagreements between we who hold to a Calvinistic position and those Lutherans we admire. One of the most striking of which is, of course, the debate over the extent of and intention of the atonement.


I know Lutherans hold to what they term "Objective Justification", what exactly that means I'm perhaps still somewhat unclear on. However, in my discussion with my Lutheran friend I noticed that there are striking similarities between his view of atonement and that of the Arminian or semi-Pelagian. (I put 'his' in italics because he may not be representative of all Lutherans.) Let me explain.

The Lutheran (please correct me if I am wrong!) view is that Christ's payment was for each and every person who ever lived, thus they are "objectively justified":

"The pattern is clear and consistent throughout: the Gospel or absolution offers not a conditional, future prospect, but a perfected, past and present reality. God already is gracious, merciful, propitious, reconciled in Christ, and freely offers this ready forgiveness or grace in the Gospel. To believe this Gospel or absolution is to believe oneself forgiven, justified, accepted. Forgiveness exists “objectively” already before faith. Faith does not create forgiveness but only receives, accepts, appropriates it." - Kurt Marquart (http://marquart4president.org/oj.shtml)

Thus the Lutheran believes that in order for there to be a 'free offer' of the Gospel, Christ's death must have paid for the sins of all those who might be potentially saved. Recently, in a webcast of the Lutheran program Issues Etc. ( http://kfuo.org/IE_Main.htm ), which by the way is a fantastic Gospel declaring program, they showcased a former "Calvinist", Dr. Leonard Payton, turned Lutheran. Of course, as often is the case when people who claim to be Calvinists convert to another view, what the person believed was not quite Calvinism but in many cases a strawman version thereof. [The program can be heard at: http://worldwide.kfuo.org/kfuo/issues_etc4/Sep_9c.wma, or http://www.kfuo.org/mp3/Issues4/Sep_9c.mp3 ]. Often during that broadcast I found myself decrying the injustice of the claims. The foremost of difficulties I had with this broadcast, however, is the idea that Calvinism "demands an answer for how/why God elects", regardless of the validity of that claim, the fact of the matter is that it is Scripture that tells us why and how God elects. It was surprising to hear during that broadcast, none of the traditional verses usually brought to the discussion was shown to be different than how Calvinism views it. Dr. Payton instead indicated instead that "the Bible doesn't provide said answer." Likewise, in my discussion with my Lutheran friend, there seems to be this ongoing view that one can easily explain away any difficult passages relating to election, atonement and justification since "God's ways are not our ways."

Yet most striking of all is the response I received when discussing the justice of universal atonement. Usually, when a Calvinist debates an Arminian (or their kin) on the subject of atonement, the conversation goes something like this:

Calvinist: "You believe that the sins of each and every person who ever lived are paid for?"

Arminian: "Yes."

Calvinist: "So on what basis does God condemn anyone?"

Arminian: "Unbelief..."

Calvinist: "Is unbelief a sin?"

Arminian: "Yes."

Calvinist: "Did Jesus pay for that sin?"

Arminian: "Yes..."

Calvinist: "So Jesus paid for everyone's sins, including the sin of unbelief, and yet God still punishes people for whose sins Jesus paid?"

Arminian: "Well... they have to accept the free gift..."

This pattern also occurs in discussions with folks of various denominations, including some NCT types (that is, seeing the Law as not condemning anyone but unbelief being the only sin) and it seems that most of us Calvinists have had this discussion with someone at some point. The most astounding thing, however, is that this conversation, while representative of those I've had with Arminians, was nearly word-for-word what I had with my Lutheran friend. The problems with this view are numerous, let me explain a few.

Firstly, and most obviously, is the problem of sin. Romans 1:18 (as well as elsewhere) states that men face the wrath of God not simply for unbelief but for "ungodliness" and "unrighteousness".

Secondly, if these sins are paid for, on what basis does God have a right to be wrathful? Does God impute to Christ sins He ultimately will punish men for? In legal terms this is "double jeopardy", a penalty demanded twice. Yet, as Arthur Custance noted: "No man can be held accountable for a debt that has already been paid for on his behalf to the satisfaction of the offended party." This is a basic legal premise, yet, it seems, one that God does not abide by. To this my Lutheran pal responded "[God] can punish sin as many times as He likes." But what does Scripture say:

Romans 8:1 Therefore there is now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus.

How can this be? If one is "in Christ Jesus" they're under no condemnation. Their sins are paid for. So far our Lutheran buddies are nodding noting that this is part of "subjective justification". Yet the questions previously posed creep back, if Christ paid for the sins of someone, how can they be condemned thereof. "Of course", says our Lutheran friend, "because they don't believe..." But again, Scripture to comes to mind:

Romans 8:34
...who is the one who condemns? Christ Jesus is He who died, yes, rather who was raised, who is at the right hand of God, who also intercedes for us.

The "us" mentioned here is of course no other than those "in Christ Jesus" who are not condemned in v. 1. The reason they are not condemned, is because of Christ's shed blood and because He is making intercession for them. My Lutheran pal insists that Christ makes intercession for those who He knows will never believe in Him.

Finally, there is the Biblical scope of atonement... that is whom the Bible declares is God's intent in the matter of atonement. It is here that our discussion gets more interesting.

The Lutherans (LCMS types) who believe in election, deny that man has a libertarian free will and clearly have so much going for them in respect to their view of law and grace, believe in universal atonement.

Yet when it comes to how this Universal Atonement is applied, the Lutherans respond:

“...when a man believes that his sins are forgiven because of Christ and that God is reconciled and favorably disposed to him because of Christ, this personal faith [fides specialis] obtains the forgiveness of sins and justifies us” - (Apology,
IV, 45)


As Karl Barth wrote: "God enables us to appropriate this salvation."

It seems therefore, that the Lutherans, upon encountering the term kosmos in Scripture have come to view it as having the same meaning as the Arminian and Universalist... world means 'each and every person who ever lived.' Regardless of the context of the passage, whether identifying Gentiles as well as Jews, or expressing a subset of the world, the view is that world, kosmos, must mean "each and every person who ever lived." Now, this might not be 100% of all verses, and I'm willing to accept that, but how do they respond to alternative position's exegetical evidence? "We cannot know."

But Biblical atonement has never applied to each and every person who ever lived, even though the plan of salvation, what the Reformed call the Covenant of Grace, included from the beginning "men from every tribe and tongue and people and nation." Abraham was not a Jew... Rahab was not a Jew (and so on). Yet when it came to the blood of the paschal lamb, it was intended to save only the people of whose doors it was applied. The sacrifices of the Day of atonement were not universal in scope, applying to the Egyptians as well as the Jews, they were made for the people of Israel alone.

This of course is, as my Lutheran friend pointed out, merely type and shadow and since the Gospel was only partially revealed, the scope of Christ's atonement cannot be rightly understood from them. This is quite true, and yet it is evident that there is much unity in these types and shadows and the reality of Christ's sacrifice on the cross. Most specifically, its intent was not for Egyptians and Greeks, but for Israel.

Before you all send Micah to the dispy-funny-farm, let me explain. Hopefully, however, most of you know where I'm headed.

Galatians 3:7
Therefore, be sure that it is those who are of faith who are sons of Abraham.

By faith in Christ we become Israel and the Jerusalem that is above becomes our mother...

Galatians 4:26
But the Jerusalem above is free; she is our mother.

It is those who are of faith then who are true Israel, as opposed to merely being blood-related to Abraham as Esau and Ishmael. (For a very interesting view about the salvation of Esau, listen to the aforementioned Issues Etc. episode...). Still with me?

Romans 4: 16
Therefore, the promise comes by faith, so that it may be by grace and may be guaranteed to all Abraham's offspring--not only to those who are of the law but also to those who are of the faith of Abraham. He is the father of us all.

Now the promise of the New Covenant was not universal in scope. It was not broadcast to the Egyptians, Greeks or even the Edomites. Instead it is written: "I WILL EFFECT A NEW COVENANT WITH THE HOUSE OF ISRAEL AND WITH THE HOUSE OF JUDAH". The scope of the New Covenant is therefore limited to a specific people. The content of the Covenant then includes as well as other things: "FOR I WILL BE MERCIFUL TO THEIR INIQUITIES, AND I WILL REMEMBER THEIR SINS NO MORE." Because of our relationship to Abraham through Christ (the Seed...), we are view as part of Israel and thus recipients of the New Covenant in the blood of Christ. It is this blood which was shed, not for all men, regardless of their faith in Him, but for His people as prophesied in the Old Testament by the types and shadows and the direct words of God Himself...

Deuteronomy 32:43
" Rejoice, O nations, with His people; For He will avenge the blood of His servants, And will render vengeance on His adversaries, And will atone for His land and His people."

It was God's intent and promise to provide atonement for His people, a people of His choosing. This theme is carried forward into the New Testament.

Acts 20: 28
"Be on guard for yourselves and for all the flock, among which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers, to shepherd the church of God which He purchased with His own blood."

The Lutheran says that Christ's blood purchased each and every person who ever lived, but Scripture states that His blood purchased the church of God. This is not the only place this idea is expressed:

Titus 2:14
who gave Himself for us to redeem us from every lawless deed, and to purify for Himself a people for His own possession, zealous for good deeds.

Thus Christ's blood did not make redemption merely possible as the Arminian believes, nor did it make men redeemable, as the Lutherans seem to believe, instead it actually accomplished what God intended.

Revelation 5: 9
And they sang a new song, saying, "Worthy are You to take the book and to break its seals; for You were slain, and purchased for God with Your blood men from every tribe and tongue and people and nation."

Far from the idea of universal atonement, here is a clear declaration that the intent of Christ was to purchase a specific people from every tribe, tongue, people and nation. This is exclusive language, not the all-inclusive view of the Lutheran or Arminian.

Of course our friends are not without their own Scriptural backing, 1 John 2:2 for example often gets mentioned, ye A.W. Pink did an excellent explanation on this verse which I will not quote in entirety, but will post a relevant portion of:

"Now believers only may take comfort from this, for they alone have an "Advocate", for them alone is Christ the propitiation, as is proven by linking the Propitiation ("and") with "the Advocate"...

...if other passages in the New Testament which speak of "propitiation," be compared with 1 John 2:2, it will be found that it is strictly limited in its scope. For example, in Rom 3:25 we read that God set forth Christ "a propitiation through faith in His blood". If Christ is a propitiation "through faith", then He is not a "propitiation" to those who have no faith!

...who are meant when John says, "He is the propitiation for our sins"? We answer, Jewish believers..." - A.W. Pink, Sovereignty of God

Obviously these statements will not completely satisfy, but I hope a Lutheran might take a careful read of Pink's evidence and respond, but I digress. It seems, then, for the Arminian these apparently conflicting verses simply prove confusing and usually result in an emotional outburst, but our Lutheran friend has already heard it before: "It is a conundrum..." he responds. "Our ways are not His ways... we cannot know...." This then becomes the reigning method of Biblical interpretation for the Lutheran whenever such a difficulty is reached, rather than reviewing the texts and examining them exegetically, they reply, simply, "we cannot know...". This sort of hermeneutic can be heard in the Issues Etc. broadcast; 'it simply is unknowable and thus we shouldn't ponder it.'

Yet it is my contention that the Bible is more than clear on these matters... election, atonement, justification... When we view the scope of atonement in the types and shadows of the Old Testament, we can see an accurate picture of Christ's intent in the New, and also verify it by His own words.

More to come?

Friday, August 27, 2004

Charles Hodge, the Roman Catholic Church, Apostasy and Baptism

"The purest Churches under heaven are subject both to mixture and error: and some have so degenerated as to become apparently no Churches of Christ. Nevertheless, there shall be always a Church on earth, to worship God according to his will. " - WCF Chapter XXV, V


In 1845, Charles Hodge objected to the decision of the Presbyterian General Assembly which denied the validity of Roman Catholic baptisms. Hodge alludes to Calvin stating that: "...those circumcised by apostate priests under the old dispensation, were never recircumcised, or treated as not having received that rite by the inspired prophets..."

Participants in the current 'reformed Catholic' conflagration have turned to Hodge's words as a source for the legitimacy of their claims. It is most certainly true, that Hodge believed in the validity of 'Romish' (his term, not mine) baptisms... and the basis for his acceptance of their validity is directly related to the fact that Hodge believed Roman Catholic priests to be appointed and recognized presbyters in a community professing to believe the scriptures.

"We maintain that as the Romish priests are appointed and recognized as presbyters in a community professing to believe the scriptures, the early creeds, and the decisions of the first four general councils, they are ordained ministers in the sense above stated; and consequently baptism administered by them is valid. It has accordingly been received as valid by all Protestant churches from the Reformation to the present day." - Charles Hodge, "Do Roman Catholic Clergy Count as Ministers of the Gospel?", Princeton Review, 1846

In so writing, Hodge has Calvin on his side in that Calvin often wrote similarly. Yet Calvin likened the Roman Catholics to the Edomites, who though circumcised rejected God through their father Esau. Thus, it seems, Calvin taught that the baptized Roman Catholic and the baptized Protestants were 'brothers' in the same way the Jews were brothers of the Edomites, with reference to Deuteronomy.

"You shall not abhor an Edomite; because he is your brother! You shall not abhor an Egyptian; because you were a stranger in his land!" - Deuteronomy 23:7

Dr. Francis Nigel Lee, in his 1990 work, "Calvin on the Validity of 'Romish' Baptism" writes of this, "Calvin argues that baptized Protestants are now far closer to baptized Romanists than either of them are to unbaptized Moslems."

Lee seems not to notice however, that Calvin was quick to point out that the Catholic was not, by virtue of his baptism saved, nor even in the Church of God proper, but rather was connected to God by the promise of baptism. "Let us therefore diligently note here of the children of [the circumcised] Esau...that if any of them would renounce his own kindred" -- as converted Papists should their kindred Romanists -- "he would be accounted in the number of this blessed flock" of God's True People."

Thus regardless of the Edomite's circumcision or the Romanist's baptism they are brothers only in the sense of the flesh, as much as Paul's Jewish brethren that he lamented over in Romans 9 and elsewhere. But we must recall what he said about them.

"...who are Israelites, to whom belongs the adoption as sons, and the glory and the covenants and the giving of the Law and the temple service and the promises... But it is not as though the word of God has failed. For they are not all Israel who are descended from Israel; nor are they all children because they are Abraham's descendants, but: "THROUGH ISAAC YOUR DESCENDANTS WILL BE NAMED." That is, it is not the children of the flesh who are children of God, but the children of the promise are regarded as descendants."

Therefore, apart from their abandonment of the apostate system, both the Edomite's circumcision and the Romanist's baptism were of no regard, and, as Paul writes "your circumcision has become uncircumcision." (Rom 2:25)

At what point then did Judaism become heretical, rather than simply apostate... that is, when did we cease considering Jews our brothers? Or does Judaism remain orthodox? If it is apostate, at what point and by what means would Rome incur the same judgment stated in the WCF as to be considedered "so degenerated as to become apparently no Churches of Christ"?

During the height of the 1846 debate within the Presbyterian Church, Hodge wrote that he believed the Roman Catholic Church was part of the 'visible church' but also pointed out that "the true, or invisible church consists of true believers". Hodge also stated, "That Romanists as a society profess the true religion, meaning thereby the essential doctrines of the gospel, those doctrines which if truly believed will save the soul, is, as we think, plain." (Is The Church of Rome a Part of the Visible Church?, Charles Hodge, Princeton Review, April 1846)

Some 26 years later, Hodge's Systematic Theology was published and therein is found:

"The doctrine of the sacrificial character of the Eucharist, is an integral part of the great system of error, which must stand or fall as a whole. Romanism is another gospel. It proposes a different method of salvation from that presented in the word of God." Charles Hodge, Systematic Theology, Part III, Ch.XX, Remarks 5. 1871~2


"The ritual system [in the Church of Rome] is utterly inconsistent with the whole genius of Christianity... The idea that a man's state before God depends on anything external, on birth, on membership in any visible organization, or on any outward rite or ceremony, is utterly abhorrent to the religion of the Bible. It did not belong to Judiasm except in the corrupt form of Pharisaism." - Charles Hodge, Systematic Theology, Part III, Ch. XX, The Sacraments. Their Necessity

Can it be said that a church whose system is "utterly inconsistent with the whole genius of Christianity" and which teaches "another gospel" and a "great system of error" also "profess the true religion, meaning thereby the essential doctrines of the gospel, those doctrines which if truly believed will save the soul"? Can a system "utterly inconsistent with the whole genius of Christianity" remains a truly Christian church?

I can't help but wonder if Hodge, later in life, found his previous views irreconcilable with the facts, or if the current users of Hodge's words aren't reading more into Hodge than he intended.

Finally, in his Systematic Theology, Hodge writes:

"In like manner, baptism does not make a man a Christian. It is the appointed means of avowing that he is a Christian; it is the badge of his Christian profession before men, it secures for him the privileges of membership in the visible Church, and it is a pledge on the part of God that, if sincere and faithful, he shall partake of all the benefits of the redemption of Christ." - Charles Hodge, Systematic Theology, Part III, Ch. XX, Baptism is a Condition of Salvation

(As a baptist, I find that admission quite sweet...) During the recent discussions there have been those who have quoted B.B. Warfield in support of their views, as one of my previous posts indicates, Warfield did not agree with everything I believe they intended to make him say... likewise those who have quoted Charles Hodge should clearly note what Hodge was intending and admit what he said in his Systematic Theology when (and if) it contradicts with their views. Plus, it might be improper to import the quotes from the battles of 19th century into our current ones without proper context.


Friday, July 30, 2004

For all those decrying the sad state of affairs regarding 'blog wars' and the like, few are willing to actually do something about it... read: shut up.

Sunday, June 20, 2004

Excellent Brews

I may be a baptist, but that doesn't mean I cannot enjoy a good ale on occasion.
Old Rasputin - Imperial Stout
This is an excellent stout. Unlike Guinness, Old Raspy's got a slightly sweeter flavor. Still, its quite a thick beverage and at 9% alcohol, packs a wallop. Raspy's are brewed in Fort Bragg, in Northern California. Thanks to Dan and Joe for introducing me to this fine brew.

Boddington's Pub Ale
Smoothest pub ale I've had so far. Perfect with just about anything. Lighter in color and heft then other pub ales, it quenches the thirst and makes a perfect companion to italian food as I found out at Vito's!Thanks to Herb for bringing over a 4 pack one evening.

Newcastle Brown Ale
I cannot recall where I first had a Newcastle, however, it has become one of my favorite beers. Especially good with crab curry and other ethnic dishes, I often have one after work while eating dinner with my wife. Newkies have a bit more intense flavor than a Boddington's and seem a bit less refined, however, I find myself craving them.

Got a favorite? Pst a comment and I'll try it out.

Saturday, June 12, 2004

B. B. Warfield - On the Church
"It is, no doubt, as a protest against the harshness of the Romanist syllogism, "No man can attain salvation who is not a member of Christ; but no one becomes a member of Christ except by baptism, received either in re or in voto," (Aquinas) that this Pelgagianizing drift is to be regarded. Its fault is that it impinges by way of mitigation and modification on the major premise, which, however, is the fundamental proposition of Christianity. Its roots are planted, in the last analysis, in a conception of men, not as fallen creatures, children of wrath, and deserving of doom which can only be escaped by becoming members of Christ, but as creatures of God with claims on Him for natural happiness, but, of course, with no claims on Him for such additional supernatural benefits as He may yet lovingly confer on His creatures in Christ. On the other hand, that great religious movement which we call the Reformation, the consititutive principle of which was its revised doctrine of the Church, ranged itself properly against the fallacious minor premise, and easily broke its bonds with the sword of the word. Men are not consituted members of Christ through the Church, but members of the Church through Christ; they are not made the members of Christ by baptism which the Church gives, but by faith, the gift of God; and baptism is the Church's recognition of this inner fact." - Benjamin Breckenridge Warfield, The Doctrine of Infant Salvation, Studies in Theology, Banner of Truth Trust, 1932, 1988

Friday, June 4, 2004

THIS IS OLD INFORMATION DO NOT FOLLOW THESE LINKS - 3/07

Links to my favorite spyware cleaning programs.



Hijackthis - the quintessential investigative app.

PestPatrol - not freeware, but highly useful and powerful.

Spyware Blaster - prevents spyware from being installed. Freeware!

Spyware Guard - companion product to Spyware Blaster

Ad-Aware - still good for finding and cleaning most malware.

CWS Shredder - cleans the most obvious forms of CoolWebSearch from your system, keep in mind though, it didn't completely get rid of it from my pc. CWS frequently changes their malware as to circumvent the spyware killers.

I no longer recommend Spybot, as it seems to have begun to lag behind in updates. Spywareinfo.com is still a good resource and clearinghouse for most of this stuff. I highly recommend all PC users get aquainted with this new form of combat against scammers and spammers.

Tuesday, June 1, 2004

New Blog Format
So... here's the new format. Unfortunately I lost all the comments. Sorry folks! I'll see what I can do about getting them back up there.