Thursday, June 29, 2006
Total Depravity - Kieran’s 1000 word rebuttal
Mark said: “Papasmurph doesn’t offer any Scripture stating that infants have a good nature, an innocent nature….” Re-read my first paper and notice especially points D and E under the heading: “This Doctrine is Unscriptural Because …” Scriptures were presented, you simply refused to deal with them.[i]
But what about their proof texts? Remember first what they are obliged to prove! The debate is not about whether men sin, are depraved on account of their own iniquity, begin to sin at an early age or even if some are totally depraved. If this debate were about such things it would not have taken place. This debate is about whether men (because of the sin of Adam) are born with a nature that is totally depraved.
Their strongest texts have been Romans 5:12-21 and 1 Corinthians 15:22, but neither passage is speaking about whether infants are born totally depraved. Furthermore, the death that is being contemplated in both passages is physical and not spiritual. (Re-read Steve’s first paper – The Fall, paragraphs 4-7 – and our response to their first and fourth questions for an explanation of this conclusion.) As Steve rightly pointed out, if we die spiritually because of Adam’s sin “then as night follows day” Romans 5:18-19 teaches universal salvation. For whatever “the many” lost unconditionally “through [Adam’s] disobedience” they regained unconditionally “through the obedience of [Christ]. Moreover, with regards to 1 Cor 15:22 if "in Adam all die" means all die spiritually, then it follows that "in Christ all shall be made alive " means that all will be given spiritual life and once again we have universal salvation.[ii]
While Calvinists say that even in the womb men are in a condition of depravity Scripture says: (Ecclesiastes 7:29) “… God made men upright, but they have sought out many devices.” Like Adam we enter the world having “no knowledge of good and evil” (Deuteronomy 1:39) and in fellowship with God. Like Adam we gain this knowledge and forfeit this fellowship through transgression (Genesis 3:22). Like him we “go astray” from God (Psalm 58:3), “turn aside” from Him and “become useless.” (Romans 3:12) Admittedly, this happens early in life, but as far as the divine record is concerned Eve too sinned the first time that Satan tempted her through the lust of the flesh, the lust of the eyes and the pride of life (Gen 3:6). Since that time Satan has tempted all the descendants of Adam (including Jesus) through the same avenues (1 John 2:15-16; Matt 4:1-11). Like Adam and Eve we do not sin because we are sinners, but we are sinners because succumb to temptation and sin. (James 1:13-15)
But what about Psalms 51:5? Calvinists fail to differentiate between the thing born and the conditions surrounding the birth. David doesn’t say: I was born in sin. Yet, had said this, it would still not mean that he was born having inherited total depravity from his mother. The fact that we are born IN something does not mean that we are THAT thing. David is not talking about the thing born, but rather about the conditions surrounding his birth. “I was brought forth in iniquity, and in sin my mother conceived me.” This is the Psalmist's description of the circumstances of his birth; it has nothing at all to do with the nature with which he came into the world.
Micah wrote: “Christ was born of woman, but was not descended from Adam.” Contrast this with Luke 3:23-38 where Jesus’ lineage is traced from his mother to Adam. Jesus is a descendant of Adam! Calvinism notwithstanding!
Micah wrote that Adam was created “not ‘totally righteous.’” If words mean anything, Micah is saying God created Adam partially unrighteous. But why take such a position? Because we asked: how could God’s word be more powerful than Satan’s since, according to Calvin's doctrine, God’s word is unable to penetrate the heart of a totally depraved person unless He first works a miracle on his heart to receive that word. For Satan’s word, without a prior miracle, was able to penetrate the heart of a totally righteous person leading her to sin. If a totally depraved individual requires a direct working of the Spirit on his heart to empower him to receive the word of God, why wouldn’t a totally righteous person require a direct work of the devil on his heart to empower him to obey his word? Is the devil’s word more powerful than God’s? According to Calvinism, “Yes!” Our opponents denial, notwithstanding.
********************
Total word count 986
[i] Mark had opportunity to address these arguments in his first paper but chose to ignore them. Thus, unless they to respond to them in this round they lose their right to respond in the final paper. For it would leave Steve and I without an opportunity to offer a rebuttal.
[ii] We made this argument previously and are merely restating it here. Therefore, unless Micah and Mark respond to it this round they lose the right to respond in their final paper. In the final paper the only NEW arguments that can be made are those written in response to NEW arguments made in this paper
Total Depravity - Micah & Mark's Final Post
Mark and I endeavored to defend the doctrine of Total Depravity from Scripture rather than by creeds or confessions. Yet our opponents sought to redirect this discussion away from Scriptural truth about man’s inability to save himself, instead focusing on what they believe to be our inconsistency regarding Reformed confessions. They attempted to redefine the Calvinist doctrine of Total Depravity but did so in opposition to the very creeds they quoted. Presenting our position as different from that which we actually hold, they painted a picture of what they thought the doctrine meant using partial quotes from the LBCF and dictionary definitions.
Murphy stated, “Micah repudiates the London Confession.” Yet he only quoted part of the confession, ignoring the portion on topic of this debate. We agree with this confession, as it explains:
"Works done by unregenerate men, although for the matter of them they may be things which God commands, and of good use both to themselves and others; yet because they proceed not from a heart purified by faith, nor are done in a right manner according to the word, nor to a right end, the glory of God, they are therefore sinful, and cannot please God, nor make a man meet to receive grace from God, and yet their neglect of them is more sinful and displeasing to God." LBCF, 16.7
Total Depravity means:
“When Calvinists speak of man as being totally depraved, they mean that man’s nature is corrupt, perverse and sinful throughout. The adjective “total” does not mean that each sinner is as totally or completely corrupt in his actions and thoughts as it is possible for him to be.” The Five Points of Calvinism: Defined, Defended and Documented, David N. Steele, Curtis C. Thomas, Presbyterian and Reformed Publishing Co., 1963
Had they actually investigated what we believed, much futile discussion could have been avoided. I post these statements only to reveal our opponents attempt to color our position. By resorting to arguments over words, they show no interest in dealing with what Calvinists actually believe (and thus what Scripture states).
Original Sin & the Effects of the Fall
Our opponents disregarded the text of Scripture during this debate and instead appealed to emotional analogies of drunken drivers. In response to Psalm 58:3, they responded:
“Psalm 58:3 teaches people were old enough to speak lies. ‘They have gone astray’ is not synonymous with born astray.”
Note that they quoted only the second half of Psalm 58:3, spinning it in such a way as to contradict the first half. Here again is the verse in question for the reader:
Psalms 58:3 (KJV) - The wicked are estranged from the womb: They go astray as soon as they are born, speaking lies.
Murphy acknowledged that “all men sin,” yet refuses to properly apply this passage to that belief. Since all men sin, all men are therefore wicked, thus all men are estranged from God from the womb. The result is that they go astray “as soon as they are born”.
Our opponents write:
”We are spiritually dead in sin not because we are born that way, but because we choose to live in sin. Psalm 58:3 teaches people were old enough to speak lies. ‘They have gone astray’ is not synonymous with born astray.”
Why do we choose to live in sin? From Scripture it can be understood that because of our fallen nature we are estranged from God from the womb. This results in our wickedness from birth. In their final rebuttal, our opponents again quoted Psalm 58:3 partially apparently realizing that to quote it fully would mean the repudiation of their position. They claimed that “we are sinners because we succumb to temptation and sin”, but what temptation has a fetus encountered? What temptation have those who speak lies been tempted with from birth?
Of Psalm 51:5, Murphy writes:
But what about Psalms 51:5? Calvinists fail to differentiate between the thing born and the conditions surrounding the birth. David doesn’t say: I was born in sin.
Consider the events surrounding David’s writing of the 51st Psalm. Scripture states: “A Psalm of David, when Nathan the prophet came to him, after he had gone in to Bathsheba.” Psalm 51 is a psalm of David’s repentance and he does not speak of other’s sin rather his own.
Psa 51:5 (KJV) Behold, I was shapen in iniquity; and in sin did my mother conceive me.
David wrote both Psalm 51 and 58. In both Psalms, he is speaking not of the conditions surrounding the individual’s conception and birth, but the individual’s condition. Murphy gives not a single reason why we should accept his view of this verse. Where is the verse that shows David’s mother as sinning by bringing him to term? Where is the verse proving that she sinned during his conception? No, Psalm 51 is the cry of a repentant sinner agonizing over his depravity and turning to God.
Our opponents have been quick to point out Scriptures explaining how children do not inherit guilt for their father’s sins, and twice likened the consequences of Adam’s sin on the rest of us as like the death of a child by the negligence of a drunken driver. One wonders who exactly the drunken driver in their analogy is, given the fact that it was God who justly cursed Adam for His sin.
Since “by the offense of one judgment came upon all men to condemnation”, then by the offense of Adam the judgment of God and condemnation unto death came to all men. Murphy acknowledges that it is God who judges and condemns, yet fails to draw the necessary conclusion from Romans 5:18. Instead, the drunk driver analogy was repeated. Do they believe it is the drunk driver who judges mankind for the one offense of Adam? One is left to wonder how, if they are not guilty for Adam’s sin, they can be judged thereby and condemned by a just God? Or is God a drunken driver, accidentally hitting you instead of Adam? Consider the inconsistency in their words:
“Adam’s sin brought physical death on all mankind…”
“According to God (who judges and condemns), we cannot inherit our father's sin, nor his guilt, nor his punishment (Ezk 18:20)….”
“I am not guilty of Adam's sin although I suffer the consequence of his sin.”
“It is only because Adam is the father of the race that "the many" (all) die as a consequence of Adam's sin.”
What are the consequences of Adam’s sin that they have nothing to do with the punishment for his sin? The Scriptures, on the other hand, state it differently: “by the offense of one judgment came upon all men to condemnation…”, what men receive as a result Adam’s offense is judgment unto condemnation by God. Our opponents’ appeal to verses such as Ezekiel 18:20, which do in fact state that children will not be punished for their father’s sin. Yet this only shows that they do not understand that it is because we are born in Adam that we are born sinners and not because of the sin of our parents.
“In truth the effects of Adam's sin did not rob man of his free will in matters of salvation.”
What relevance ‘free-will’ has in this discussion is questionable. Jesus states that “everyone who sins is a slave of sin”. While the Pharisees claimed not to be “slaves of anyone,” Jesus places them all under the same condemnation explaining that only “if the Son makes you free, you will be free indeed.” Since all sin, no man is free, instead we are all slaves to sin and require a Savior to free him from that state. Paul writes:
2 Timothy 2:24-26
The Lord's bond-servant must not be quarrelsome, but be kind to all, able to teach, patient when wronged, with gentleness correcting those who are in opposition, if perhaps God may grant them repentance leading to the knowledge of the truth, and they may come to their senses and escape from the snare of the devil, having been held captive by him to do his will.
Dead in Sin
As I stated in the opening round, Romans 8:7-9 adequately addresses the nature of man apart from the Spirit of God as being “set on the flesh” and “hostile toward God”. These do not and cannot subject themselves to the Law of God, and cannot please God. The question posed to our opponents was: “given… the difference between 'natural man' and 'spiritual man' is the indwelling Spirit of God (Rom 8:9), how is it that you believe unbelievers are able to do the opposite?” Their response was:
“Micah and Mark teach "the mind set on the flesh" is also absolute. They see "the hostility," the "cannot subject" and "cannot please God" as absolute….
Having said that, the natural man still has free will, so the syndrome is not necessarily permanent or irreversible…”
This is no answer, their response seems only to be ‘cannot cannot mean cannot’! Yet, nothing in the text of Romans 8 supports this condition as being “not necessarily permanent.” Romans 8:7-8 instead declares that the person with the mind set on the flesh cannot obey God and are unable to please Him. The difference between the person with the mind set on the flesh and the person with the mind set on the Spirit is the indwelling Spirit of God. Romans 8 thus proves what we are saying, that apart from the indwelling Spirit of God men cannot obey God nor please Him. Our opponents’ conclusion therefore is without substantiation.
“Some natural men can be mildly interested in the spiritual or even attend church regularly,” Murphy writes. Calvinism in no way states otherwise, but that natural man cannot obey God and is unable to please Him. Although natural man may seek solace in churches and monasteries, he does so out of sinful motives. As in Christ’s day, the Pharisees were leaders in the church yet Christ called them ‘children of… the devil.’
John 8:47
“He who is of God hears the words of God; for this reason you do not hear them, because you are not of God.”
Note the inability implied: “…you cannot hear my word…” and “He who is of God hears the words of God”. This is similar to John 10 wherein Jesus explains that the Pharisees do not believe because they are not His sheep, rather than the other way around.
That natural man can do that which appears to be good in no way diminishes the fact that he is unable to please God or perfectly obey His Law. As we stated, God commanding something does not imply ability to fulfill the command. God commanded Israel to obey the Law fully, and yet no one except Christ was able to do that. Therefore, it is only by faith in Christ that the perfect obedience to God’s Law is imputed to the believer.
Augustine fought Pelagius over these very issues. The end result of that debate was the excommunication of Pelagius, and the naming of the particular heresy after him. That debate took place well over 1600 years ago, but the heresy then condemned continues. Our opponents are but recent followers of the same line of thinking and are likewise condemned. This debate has clearly exposed the anthropocentric nature of their belief system. Denying original sin, they affirm that infants are not“estranged from the womb” and do not “come forth speaking lies” but are all born perfectly sinless. If what they believe is true, infants do not need a Savior, especially not a Savior who bore in His own flesh the sin of His people! By denying Total Depravity they claim unregenerate man can cooperate with God. They thus add works to grace, cheapening that work of Christ and denying the imputation of righteousness claiming that all men have that which Satan tempted Eve with… the ability to what only God can do.
Soli Deo Gloria
Micah Burke
Total Depravity - "Hereditary Total Depravity" - Kieran & Steve's Final Post
Mark did a runner. He agreed to debate Hereditary Total Depravity but then tried to change it to the depravity of the total man. Mark did not even attempt to answer Kieran's first paper. Mark you signed up to debating Hereditary Total Depravity but you failed to discharge your duty. Shame on you!
Kieran accused Mark of believing that "Infants possess a nature identical to that of Satan himself." Mark's reply was "So what if that is the case? … Scripture makes no differentiation between the nature of children, and the nature of anyone else." Let us see. Scripture calls God, "The Father of spirits" (Heb 12:9). He formed our spirit within us (Zech 12:1b). If as Calvinists teach, the soul is spiritually corrupt, then it stands to reason, God is responsible for it's corruption. How repulsive! Jesus called a child to Himself and set him before them and said, "Truly I say to you, unless you are converted and become like children, you will not enter the kingdom of heaven" (Mt 18:2-3). Mark, you could never say, "unless you are converted and become like children" (Mt 19:14). The Scripture also says, "For though the twins (Rebekah's) were not yet born and had not done anything good or bad" (Rom 9:11). HTD is a denial of that passage. "Brethren, do not be children in your thinking; yet in evil (Gr. KAKIA, stands for whatever is evil in character, badness in quality) be infants" (1 Cor 14:20). Think about it! No difference in the nature of a child and an adult, rubbish! The Holy Spirit assures us that small children do not know enough to refuse evil and choose good (Isa 7:16). Mark thinks all these Scriptures are "an anecdotal appeal to emotion." How sad!
When Mark affirms about Christ "If sin cannot be imputed then salvation is impossible," he is also implying the imputation of Adam's sin to his descendants in that statement. But when he talks about Ezekiel 18 he contradicts himself by saying, "Total Depravity does not mean that each person bears the sins of their father and so on." Well Mark, Adam is our father so we cannot bear his sin! Your Westminster Confession of Faith teaches, that the guilt of this transgression was also imputed to their children, "and the same death in sin … conveyed to all their posterity" (chap VI, Art. 3). Mark you are contradicting the WCF as well as yourself! The legs of the lame are not equal!
Micah gave a number of verses to try to prove Hereditary Total Depravity. Romans 3:10-18 is typical of the passages used. The passage teaches, "all have turned aside, together they have become useless." This verse does not say, "all were conceived astray and were born useless." So, Micah, this passage (and the others) do not prove your THD doctrine. The truth is we cannot sin by proxy because sin is something we do ourselves, "But each one is tempted when he is carried away and enticed by his own lust. Then when lust is conceived, it gives birth to sin; and when sin is accomplished, it brings forth death" (Js 1:14-15). "Sin is lawlessness" (1 Jn 3:4). A newborn infant has not broken God's law. S/he is not guilty of any sin.
M&M say, "There is nothing in Scripture to suggest Adam was inherently righteous." Yet the Scripture says, "Behold, I have found only this, that God made men upright, but they have sought out many devices" (Eccl 7:29). "For you were blameless in your ways from the day that you were created until unrighteousness was found in you" (Ezk 28:15). Adam was made upright in God’s image (Isa 26:7; Ps 25:8; 92:15). The word upright means, "honest, honourable or just." Adam bore the image of God. He was blameless, upright and without unrighteousness. He was therefore inherently righteous. Yet, M&M said, “There is nothing in Scripture to suggest Adam was inherently righteous.” Who do you believe M&M or Scripture?
Mark conveniently overlooks so much in Ezekiel 18. Mark does not say anything about the wicked becoming righteous or the righteous man losing his salvation by turning to wickedness. It is very revealing to substitute (natural man) for wicked, and (Spirit led man) for righteous. Try it and see. Mark also turns a blind eye to God's confirmation of man's ability to "turn from his ways and live" (Vss 23, 30-32). Note this chapter by itself answers his "inability of man" argument!
Verse 20 says, God's way is to treat each person individually so the sinner alone will bear the guilt and/or the punishment for his own sin. Incredibly M&M quote "The wickedness of the wicked will be upon himself," to prove the very opposite, namely, we all bear the guilt and the punishment of Adam's sin. I am reminded of a sign over an ironmonger's shop, "All sorts of fancy twisting and turning done here."
Throughout this debate Kieran and I have given a detailed commentary on each verse in Romans 5:12-21. Reader please take note, we have not been afforded the same courtesy from Mark and Micah. Our position is abundantly clear and consistent (re-read note 1 on the Questions and Answers paper).
This is a summation of note 1. The "free gift" (V 15) is not like the transgression (Adam's), in that the "free gift" (life, temporal and eternal) arose because of many transgressions (all human transgressions including Adam's). By implication the effects of Christ's obedience is "much more" comprehensive because the resulting justification covers the "one transgression" and the "many transgressions."
By the transgression of the one (Adam) death reigned through the one (unconditionally). "Much more," (although all men have been reconciled to God unconditionally, they have to receive the reconciliation through Christ, for eternal life (2 Cor 5:18-20). So only those who receive (conditionally) the abundance of grace (the reconciliation) and the gift of righteousness (forgiveness and being counted righteous by God) will reign in life through One, Jesus Christ (V 17).
Verses 18-19 returns to what happened in Adam and how the death of Christ counteracts (unconditionally) the curse of physical death that befell all of us because of Adam's sin.
Vss 20-21 shows how the proliferation of personal sins (under the Law) is covered along with the sin of Adam, in the free gift. By implication "the justification to life" of verse 19 leaves room to incorporate those who (conditionally) receive the abundance of grace.
So the reign of sin in death (both temporal and eternal) is broken. Grace now reigns through righteousness to eternal life, for those who (conditionally) receive the abundance of grace.
I have noticed when we have exposed a problem in Mark's position; he uses a decoy tactic. By finding what he perceives to be a flaw and exaggerating it, he diverts the eye of the reader away from himself and on to his opponents. The reader then thinks we have the problem, when all the while he is the one with the problem. He pretends he had no difficulties with his interpretation of these verses. Let us see if that is true.
They say, V12 teaches that death (both physical and spiritual) entered the world through Adam. In keeping with this, Calvinism teaches we all sinned in Adam and the sin was imputed to his descendants.
However, Paul argues in V's 13-14, that death reigned even over those who had not sinned in the likeness of Adam's offence. Friends, M&M denies this, they believe like Roman Catholics, that we are guilty of Adam's sin and we died spiritually and physically because we actually sinned in Adam. They affirm what Paul denies! Is Paul right or are M&M and the Catholics right?
When Vss 15-16 say, "But the free gift is not like the transgression." Mark & Micah again say the opposite. They say the judgment arose from "one transgression" resulting in condemnation to all men. And the free gift arose from "many transgressions" resulting in justification (spiritual life) to the many (the elect). This reductionism makes the contrast in V16 between the "one transgression" and the "many transgressions" null and void. Friends, Calvinists have the problem with the ‘alls’ in these verses. They teach “justification of life” applies only to the elect not to all men. So they contract and expand the ‘alls’ in these verses to suit their doctrine. No, Mark, we do not have a problem with the ‘alls.’ You do!
The "much more" of V 17 becomes "much less" in their interpretation because according to Calvin Christ's justification to life only covers the elect.
Micah's comment on Vss 18-19 is revealing, "Adam's fall," he said, "brought 'condemnation to all men,' … and the second Adam brings 'justification of life,'" but he deliberately left out, "to all men" (v 18). Why did he do that? Because Calvinists have a problem with "all men" in these verses. Although they see, "the condemnation" (spiritual and physical death) is to all men, when it comes to "the justification of life," they do not want it to be to all but to many. Since the verse says "to all men," then all men are saved. If this does not add up to universal salvation then 1+1=3.
I would like to know since all men are condemned (spiritually and physically) in Adam, could individual transgressions make them any more condemned? If not then the idea of grace abounding (V 20-21) is nonsense.
Good reader none of these monumental problems were tackled. No explanation offered. So don't be fooled by Mark's decoy.
M&M are going to poke fun at my description of the natural man. Please re-read point 3 on my Questions and Answers paper. Their elucidation of the natural man makes him nothing more than a robot preprogrammed by God for failure. He cannot change unless the Programmer installs a program for change. However God will not do that because God wants the natural man to fail. He must fail because God destined him for hell.
The Scriptures teach that Adam and Eve sinned in the garden of Eden (Job 31:33). They were driven away from the tree of life so they could not eat and live forever (Gen 3:24). Because their descendants had no access to the tree of life, they also were doomed to die physically (Rom 5:12). When a child is conceived God forms the spirit in each one (Zech 12:1). Although born into a sinful world, each child is pure and sinless in the image of God (Eccl 7:29). However, in their youth they go astray by sinning against God (Gen 8:21). They are then (spiritually) dead in their transgressions and sins (Eph 2:1-3). God makes them aware of the imminent danger they are in through the Gospel (Mk 16:15-16). He points out Jesus is the way, the truth and the life. That no one comes to the Father but by Him (Jn 14:6). God demands a freewill response from us. We must believe (Jn 8:24), repent (Lk 24:47), and be baptized for the forgiveness of sins (Acts 2:38). Being born again of water and the Spirit makes us children of God (Jn 3:3,5). Christians must then co-operate with God by setting their minds on the things of the Spirit (Rom 8:5-7) for eternal life. Through repentance, God continues to justify us (forgive our sins and count us righteous) in this way our eternal life is secured (1 Jn 1:5-10).
The reader will see that Kieran and myself answered the arguments and Scripture presented. We take seriously "Anyone who goes too far and does not abide in the teaching of Christ has not God. He who abides in the teaching has both the Father and the Son" (2 Jn 9). For our part, we were deeply concerned to explain every Scripture in its context, and to have it harmonize with all other Scriptures. It seems Mark and Micah were more concerned about their theology than word of God (2 Tim 3:16-17).
Hereditary Total Depravity is unscriptural, and it has not been proved Scriptural in this debate.
Steve Kearney
Thursday, May 11, 2006
DCT6412 Comcast Remote Control Unlocking Mute
I got sick and tired of that, my wife records Martha every day so that when I get home i cannot watch CSI or something... worthwhile. ;) So I googled and googled and found the following fix. Keep in mind, this UNLOCKS the volume control on the DVR, changing the volume on the TV after this will require you to hit the TV button and then use the volume, thought the DVR may have its own volume control.
CHANGING VOLUME LOCK
The Comcast Custom 3-Device universal remote control is set at the factory to control the TV volume in all modes. However, you may change the Volume Lock setting to Individual Volume Unlock to unlock a specific device’s volume controls for independent operation in its own mode (e.g., Audio Receiver volume controls in the AUX mode).
Unlocking Volume Control For A Single Device (Individual Volume Unlock):
1. Press a desired mode key where you want volume to be unlocked (e.g., Cable) and controlled within its own mode.
2. Press and hold Setup until the selected mode key blinks twice, then release Setup.
3. Enter 9 - 9 - 3 and then press VOL once. The mode key will blink four times confirming unlock.
4. If desired, repeat steps 1 to 3 (of this section) for each device that
you want volume to be unlocked.
5. Now, after you select a device that has volume unlocked (e.g., AUX),pressing VOL+, VOL-, or Mute, will control the device’s volume only in its own mode.
Hope this helps folks out there googling!
Now... to get a firewire card on my HTPC (Home Theater PC) and record the programs off of it. (Help for that here.)
Wednesday, May 10, 2006
Christian Defense
Monday, May 8, 2006
Major Photoshop CS2 Bug
Tuesday, May 2, 2006
Monday, April 17, 2006
Thursday, February 23, 2006
"Between faith and reason"
I realize you're not looking for a review of the article, however, I can't help but note a few items.
While the author highlights a problem within the general evangelical 'Christian' population that views faith and reason at odds and also correctly identifies secular humanism as a "religion... without (God)." there are some general historical errors of this piece, i.e. "Martin Luther and John Calvin approved the slaughter of Anabaptists..." and the reexamining of history though a specifically anti-religious lens, "A third of the population of Germany perished during a single 30-year doctrinal dispute between Catholics, Lutherans and Calvinists", suggesting that a single doctrinal dispute separated those groups and caused the chaos that was ultimately the result of the leadership of the countries involved and had little to do with issues faith.
That said, I think the author improperly views Christianity as a religion based on faith, as if faith was opposed to reason. It is evident they do so based on many Christian's view of their own faith as a subjectively embraced experience, rather than a reasoned understanding of the historical fact of Christ and His work. The author's example of President's Bush seemingly direct-from-God order to invade certain countries is evidence of this idea.
The question before us is not whether faith is legitimate or which faith is best. It is: Shall we allow the divine experience of one group to control the behavior of those with a different experience?
Let us work to see that the answer to that question remains an unequivocal, "No."
How far do we take this? We've reached the point in society where "murder" is defined as matter of faith, not reason, as is the case in abortion... I think Van Til was right, at least on this issue, its not "if god" but "which (G)od". A society whose morals (as if there can be "morals" in a system that accepts and promotes secular humanistic evolution as a fact) are subjective, based on the whims of the majority is only a short step away from anarchy.
It is important for us to strive to express our faith in reason-based, fact-based and history-based ways and to encourage other believers to think likewise. Christ is not some subjective personal thought, but rather a collectively embraced historical figure who really did what the Bible claims and thus our faith is based on real events that really accomplished what God declares in His Word declares they did.
Also, when Scientific "facts" seem to indicate something different than what the Church believes the Bible states, perhaps it is the interpretation of Scripture, rather than the Scriptures themselves that are at odds with the universe. For example, the Roman Catholic Church taught that the Earth was the center of the universe and that the Sun and other solar bodies orbited around it. They seemingly took this belief from Scripture, claiming that certain verses taught it ( http://radongas.blogspot.com
This revamping of tradition can only be taken so far, however, there are certain things clearly taught in Scripture that may not be apparent in the revealed universe. Theistic evolution, for example, is an attempt at revamping the first chapters of Genesis as to conform to a proposed scientific theory, diluting both concepts as to make them untenable. This leads to concepts such as "intelligent design", which is not Biblical creation. While I admit that the Bible shouldn't be used as a scientific text, it is usually our tradition, not Scripture which conflict with the "evidence" science discovers in the world around us. ( http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap
One final example of the type of problematic tradition that may be overturned by scientific discovery has to do with the potential for genetic pre-disposition toward homosexuality. For years evangelical Christians have argued and continue to argue that there is no, cannot be, will never be found a genetic marker or clue for a predespotisition for homosexuality, yet if (and when) such a genetic link is made it could only be denied by those Christians. I however view this staunch evangelical view as founded in tradition, not in Scripture which teaches that we're all "born in sin" and dead in Adam from conception... the fact that one may have a genetic disposition toward one sinful expression of that deadness or another should therefore not surprise us.
To reiterate then what I said previously, it is of the utmost importance that we who recognize the false-dichotomy between faith and reason seek to establish and express the true nature of faith as grounded in reason and the facts of Scripture and history and yet maintain faith as a supernatural gift of our Lord.
Wednesday, February 22, 2006
Pietism ATTACKS!
Monday, February 13, 2006
"If thou therefore wilt worship me..."

Luke 4:6-7While they've since changed the image back, Dharp got an image of it for me!
And the devil said to Him, "I will give You all this domain and its glory; for it has been handed over to me, and I give it to whomever I wish. Therefore if You worship before me, it shall all be Yours."
For those who don't know, the U.C.C. stands for "United Church of Christ" who's distinctives include: "We believe that everyone – old, young, straight, lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgendered, physically or emotionally challenged, rich or poor, sure or unsure, lost or found, Democrat or Republican has a place in the body of Christ."
Seems to me that the verse properly identified their beliefs!
Friday, February 10, 2006
Geocentrism Challenge
Catholic Apologetics International is holding a "Geocentrism Challenge" wherein they're offering $1000 to anyone who can "prove" that the earth orbits the eun. They claim that their tradition and certain Bible passages require that the sun orbit the earth.
I have no interest in CAI's cash, but I am interested in the Bible verses they claim teach geocentrism. So here are their "proof" verses from the Bible (apocryphal ones excluded.) Keep in mind that poetic language is not intended to be taken literally. I can say the "sun sets", even though the earth is that which is rotating and still be correct from my vantage point.
Psa 19:5-7
Which is as a bridegroom coming out of his chamber;
It rejoices as a strong man to run his course.
Its rising is from one end of the heavens,
And its circuit to the other end of them;
And there is nothing hidden from its heat.
The law of the LORD is perfect, restoring the soul;
The testimony of the LORD is sure, making wise the simple.
Psa 104:5
He established the earth upon its foundations, So that it will not totter forever and ever.
Psa 104:19
He made the moon for the seasons; The sun knows the place of its setting.
Psa 119:90
Your faithfulness continues throughout all generations; You established the earth, and it stands.
Ecc 1:5
Also, the sun rises and the sun sets; And hastening to its place it rises there again.
2 Kings 20:9-11
Isaiah said, "This shall be the sign to you from the LORD, that the LORD will do the thing that He has spoken: shall the shadow go forward ten steps or go back ten steps?"
So Hezekiah answered, "It is easy for the shadow to decline ten steps; no, but let the shadow turn backward ten steps."
Isaiah the prophet cried to the LORD, and He brought the shadow on the stairway back ten steps by which it had gone down on the stairway of Ahaz.
2 Chron 32:24
In those days Hezekiah became mortally ill; and he prayed to the LORD, and the LORD spoke to him and gave him a sign.
Isa 38:7-8
"This shall be the sign to you from the LORD, that the LORD will do this thing that He has spoken:
"Behold, I will cause the shadow on the stairway, which has gone down with the sun on the stairway of Ahaz, to go back ten steps " So the sun's shadow went back ten steps on the stairway on which it had gone down."
Joshua 10:12-14
...So the sun stood still, and the moon stopped... And the sun stopped in the middle of the sky and did not hasten to go down for about a whole day...
Judges 5:31
"Thus let all Your enemies perish, O LORD; But let those who love Him be like the rising of the sun in its might."
And the land was undisturbed for forty years.
Job 9:7
Who commands the sun not to shine,
And sets a seal upon the stars;
Habakkuk 3:11
Sun and moon stood in their places;
They went away at the light of Your arrows,
At the radiance of Your gleaming spear.
James 1:12 - Blessed is a man who perseveres under trial; for once he has been approved, he will receive the crown of life which the Lord has promised to those who love Him.
None of these verses say what CAI wants them to say, thus it is not the Bible which directs their misguided belief but their tradition.
Tuesday, February 7, 2006
Not a Funny Story.
A guest pastor was filling in for a pastor who was out of town. He'd just finished the sermon and was standing at the door greeting people who were leaving.A man who had just started attending the church, who's understanding of the Word of God was quite limited, approached the group of men standing near the pastor and, introducing himself, spoke of his appreciation for the pastor's message. Then, as he was about to leave the man noted that he was under obligation to his wife to go home and mow the lawn.
The pastor, shocked at the bold declaration by the man, berated him about not keeping the Sabbath and asked him if it was honoring God to mow his lawn on the Sabbath. This continued for a few minutes. The man, not knowing what to say, having never studied the Sabbath laws left in confusion.
All those of you with big leather bibles or have your wife cook dinner better study what the word says...
Jeremiah 17:22
"You shall not bring a load out of your houses on the sabbath day nor do any work, but keep the sabbath day holy, as I commanded your forefathers.
Colossians 2:16
Therefore no one is to act as your judge in regard to food or drink or in respect to a festival or a new moon or a Sabbath day--
Hebrews 4:9-10
So there remains a Sabbath rest for the people of God. For the one who has entered His rest has himself also rested from his works, as God did from His.
Monday, February 6, 2006
UN Colors!

Desperation... that's all it could be. British media is reporting that a Brit professor, Phillipe Sands, has written a book in which he claims that he saw a 'Downing St. memo' (dramatic music here) wherein President George Bush and Prime Minister Tony Blair considered "flying U2 reconnaissance aircraft planes with fighter cover over Iraq, painted in UN colours" in hopes they'd be shot down and thus precipitate a war with Iraq. Sir Menzies Campbell, the Liberal Democrat acting leader, said last night: "The fact that consideration was apparently given to using American military aircraft in UN colours in the hope of provoking Saddam Hussein is a graphic illustration of the rush to war."
Being somewhat of an aviation buff, I have to question the accuracy of these supposed memos (not to mention the intelligence of said "professor") on the basis of the stupidity of the claim of Bush wanting to paint a U2 in "UN Colors" just to goad the world to attack Iraq. Several things to consider:
1) Though the U-2 has become less useful in this age of satellites and cell phones, to suggest that a US president would sacrifice one (not to mention its pilot) is simply stupid. As of 2005 there were only 29 active Air Force aircraft and 5 two-seaters. The two civilian ER-2's are based at the Dryden Flight Research Center. (See photo.)
2) Any "UN" patrol aircraft over the Iraq no-fly zone carry the markings of the nation from which they come (US or UK). Thus American planes enforcing the no-fly zone had... American markings not some "neutral" UN markings, yet they were still designated UN flights.
3) The U-2 is an American-made plane and there are no U2 aircraft in operation for other nations. Every media outlet and reader of Tom Clancy knows this, no "UN colors" would fool anyone.
2) Iraq was already locking-onto and shooting surface to air missles at UN patrols (US and British aircraft.) Iraq was in constant violation of UN resolutions since the end of the first Gulf War. Far from a "rush to war", Iraq's non-compliance and constant defiance of UN resolutions and international law was renowned. There was no need to create a situation.
4) The U-2's operational flight level is 70k ft. Nothing in the Iraqi arsenal, except for other aircraft, can hit something at this flight level. Note also the claim made by the Guardian paper is that the U2 would have fighter escort... at 70,00 ft no fighter could obtain operational flight level to maintain escort.
5) Finally... what are "UN colors"? Since aircraft flying for the UN still maintain their country of origin's markings as well as a UN monogram on the tail. One wonders then how a U-2 spy plane carring US as well as UN markings spur a war with Iraq any more than the constant attacks already occuring?
It seems desperation is the order of the day for the liberal mindset. It is evident that they cannot make up their minds whether President Bush is a imbecile or a genius and here is yet one more example. Maybe the fictional pres wanted to fly a U-2 with the cute powder blue helmet over iraq with a the French flag (isn't that a blank white one?) on it!?
Wednesday, January 18, 2006
Thursday, January 5, 2006
Friday, December 16, 2005
Comcast Woes
I was told by a phone-op that I'd receive all the channels mentioned on that line-up page, when in fact I would only get the channels "above 120"... they offered to upgrade me for $26 for the first three months... but what good does that do, I still end up paying $50 a month afterwards.
Secondly, Comcast sends people out to install cable cards who don't have a clue what they're doing. Fortunately there's some good folks in their service dept who are interested in helping customers.
Monday, December 12, 2005
The Most Repugnant Element of Christianity & Narnia
“Of all the elements of Christianity, the most repugnant is the notion of the Christ who took our sins upon himself and sacrificed his body in agony to save our souls. Did we ask him to?”Yes, it is repugnant to think that God sent His one and only Son to die upon the cross that you might be reconciled to God, and no... you didn't ask Him to, and that's why He had to do it. We preach Christ crucified, to Jews a stumbling block and to Gentiles foolishness... For the word of the cross is foolishness to those who are perishing, but to us who are being saved it is the power of God. She truly has stumbled over the stumbling stone, the rock of offense.
Notice how this writer quickly appeals to the "gospel" of Norman V. Peale in her diatribe against the Gospel of Christ... as if the Gospel of redemption in Scripture has anything whatsoever in common with that snakeoil. Another reason to stand up to such crap is how it misrepresents our Savior's sacrifice.
Yes, I will be unhappy with the Narnia machine coming soon to a church near you, but it is telling to see that enough of the Gospel remains in this Disney film to offend such as she.
She ends with "We need no holy guide books, only a very human moral compass." She would do well to note that others do not share her 'moral compass' and indeed would find her very life and breath more repugnant than she finds the underlying thread in the Narnia series... her basis then for a universal moral compass is without basis except in the law imprinted on one's own heart by the very God of the Bible she reviles.
Monday, December 5, 2005
Rom 7, an indicator.
While NCT would not consider the Law the Christian is under today to be the 10 Commandments but rather the "law of Christ", meaning the commands of Christ expressed in the New Testament, they would agree with some of the FV types who claim that the Law of God was never intended as a perfect standard of righteousness.
Walmart - Bad for America?
This article in the Wall Street Journal's opinion pages highlights some problems within the structure of Wal-Mart's corporate society. I've notice other problems relating to Wal-Mart, which I'll highlight here. I'm sure this post will bring some interesting responses.
Unless Wal-Mart reinvents itself, soon, it will go the way of Kmart... and I think this trend has already begun. My observation of Kmart comes at the price of many years of school-yard ridicule for wearing knock-off jeans and nagahide bomber jackets. (I now protest the depletion of the vast herds of naga.)
Kmart always low-balled prices, and in so doing their targeted clientele were the working-poor and low-middle class who needed the bargain. Kmart also followed the tradition that more-is-better in respect to stock on-hand and thus whenever a 'new thing' came out, Kmart carried it. As the years went by, that clientele shifted from generally Caucasians to minorities, locally typified as migrant workers from Central America hired to pick produce in the local fields of
Kmart’s aisles became cluttered and disorganized and the whole store, nearly every one you might visit, was trashed. Finally, when trying on a pair of pants I was greeted with a pile of human excrement in the corner of the stall. This could all be of bad hiring practices, poor management or a number of other things (and certainly are); however I believe that they also reflect the mindset of those who, while visiting their local store, left wearing 5 of those plaid shirts, unpaid. It seemed to me that in so shifting their scope, Kmart lost their foundation clients who originally went there for the nagahide and yet were planning to return for the Panasonic TV and in turn was seeking clients who weren't used to American-style markets where changing rooms didn't double for toilets.
Now, I by no way mean to imply that every migrant, every Hispanic, etc has no common sense or anything of the sort. I was and I am friends with many people of minority background who would also find such things disturbing, however, Kmart wasn't targeting people interested in becoming part of our society, but those who visited the US temporarily and had no intentions of staying. Like the folks who rent a cabin for a weekend and leave it trashed, some of these folks seem intent on using the
Fast forward a few years and where I live now I've got a Wal-Mart about a mile away. When we first moved to this location we were happy at the proximity given Wal-Mart’s selection of products. However, within a year I noticed a similar shift going on at Wal-Mart. The aisles became cluttered, the lines longer, the products on-hand were of terrible quality and the whole experience became such that I simply refused to shop there. The single event that sealed my opinion occurred while waiting in an overly-long line. I was subjected to an overly loud commercial blasting at me from a finger-print smudged LCD screen. The real clincher was... it was in Spanish.
I live in a very ethnically diverse area, and I enjoy the diversity. The local Asian market down the street offers many goods that I would normally not see or try. There is also a very unusual, rancid actually, smell to the market. I understand that it comes from the dried fish aisle, but to one who has never visited such a place, that smell would certainly drive them away. But that said, I expect that smell when I enter this market, it's an Asian market, targeting the local population of Asians for whom dried fish is a normal smell. Thus I don't expect them to have commercials in English advertising their dried fish to me. We also have a large Hispanic population nearby, and there you'd be hard-pressed to find signage, advertisements or products labeled in English. Which is understandable, to some extent? But was does my local Wal-Mart blast a commercial at me in a language other than that I was taught in school?
Now I realize that English-speakers are not the only folks who visit Wal-Mart, and I understand their desire to attract further customers and inform them of other products available, but Wal-Mart needs to be conscious of this decision they're making to appeal to non-English speakers and those who seem intent on not conforming or are simply visitors here and the problems it may lead.
When I saw this commercial, standing line at Wal-Mart, I realized that I wasn't their target client any longer. They did have a commercial in English soon-thereafter, but the whole experience reminded me of Kmart and suddenly the out-of-control appearance of my local Wal-Mart began to make sense. Is it possible that by targeting clients who have little interest in the ongoing success of your store, your community, or your country you're also hurting your own bottom line?
There's much more to this than what I've said here. Questions of targeted advertising, community-matched products and the like all relate to a store's success or failure. Perhaps also I'm shopping in the 'wrong places'. I find myself at Target now much more often than ever at Wal-Mart. There I find I'm surrounded by as diverse a collection of people as at Wal-Mart, but then again, I don't find Target aggressively marketing products in foreign languages on LCD screens... yet.