Thursday, March 20, 2008

Deepak Chopra's Jesus

Deepak Chopra, that Oprah-crowned guru of modern spirituality, thinks he has something to say about the historical Jesus. In his article, he decries what he believes are people making Jesus in their own image, and then proceeds to do the same thing.

Deepak seems to think himself a Biblical scholar when he writes: "The legacy of love found in the New Testament has been tainted with the worst sort of intolerance and prejudice that would have appalled Jesus in life." Chopra is not lamenting the actions of evil doers, rather he is actually describing how he views Scripture.
The first Jesus is less than consistent, as a closer reading of the gospels will show. If Jesus was perfectly peaceful, why did he declare, "Do not suppose that I have come to bring peace to the earth. I did not come to bring peace, but a sword"? (Matthew 10:34) If he was perfectly loving, why did he say, "Throw out the unprofitable servant into the outer darkness, where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth"? (Matthew 25:30) (Sometimes the translation is even harsher, and Jesus commands "the worthless slave" to be consigned to hell.) If Jesus was humble, why did he claim to rule the earth beyond the power of any king? At the very least, the living Jesus was a man of baffling contradictions.
If Deepak was graced by God to understand the words of Christ as provided in Scripture, he'd realize that these are not "baffling contradictions" but rather consistent statements of God incarnate. Deepak, of course, has no interest in the consistent Jesus of Scripture and thus these threatening words of the Sovereign God who has foreordained Chopra's destiny cannot fit into his worldview. (One should compare Chopra's words to those of John MacArthur on the Larry King program a few years back. Peaceful little Chopra got very angry on that show.)

Chopra doesn't even understand Christian theology which he now seeks to contradict, in his article he writes:
"Millions of people worship another Jesus, however, who never existed, who doesn't even lay claim to the fleeting substance of the first Jesus. This is the Jesus built up over thousands of years by theologians and other scholars. He is the Holy Ghost, the Three-in-One Christ, the source of sacraments and prayers that were unknown to the rabbi Jesus when he walked the earth. He is also the Prince of Peace over whom bloody wars have been fought. This second Jesus cannot be embraced without embracing theology first. Theology shifts with the tide of human affairs. Metaphysics itself is so complex that it contradicts the simplicity of Jesus's words. Would he have argued with learned divines over the meaning of the Eucharist? Would he have espoused a doctrine declaring that babies are damned until they are baptized?"

...Isn't it a direct contradiction to hold that Jesus was a unique creation—the one and only incarnation of God—while at the same time claiming to be able to read his mind on current events?...
Notice Chopra's faulty understanding of our faith. He combines the Son with the Holy Spirit, and declares Him a "three-in-one Christ". If Chopra was really wanting to discuss who Christ was, he might at least declare what we believe rightly. He declares the sacraments to be "unknown to the rabbi Jesus", but who is Chopra to dismiss the words of Scripture (which he will later embrace in certain ways)? Chopra cannot imagine a God who would willingly suffer and die to save His creations, a God who would give His own flesh and blood to sustain and save.

Notice his misunderstanding of the incarnation, he states: "Jesus was a unique creation—the one and only incarnation of God" No orthodox Christian can claim Jesus was "a unique creation", for he is the uncreated, God incarnate. The contradictions Chopra decries are based not on the text of Scripture, nor any real claim of metaphysics, but Chopra's worldview.

Who made Deepak Chopra a textual critic schooled in understanding ancient texts? On what basis can he dismiss the words of Christ in the Scriptures in order to declare that Jesus didn't know "the sacraments"? How can a man so many look to for "spiritual" advice be so ignorant when it comes to Christianity?

Deepak just acknowledged previously that Scripture states that Jesus said: "Do not suppose that I have come to bring peace to the earth. I did not come to bring peace, but a sword...", so why does it suprise him that "He is also the Prince of Peace over whom bloody wars have been fought"? The inconsistency here lies not with Scripture, or Jesus, but within the evil pagan mind of Deepak Chopra.

So when Chopra says "Millions of people worship another Jesus, however, who never existed", he does so only on the basis of his belief structure, not upon any basis in fact, or in the eyewitness testimony of the Apostles and writers of the documentation closest to the events that occurred. When Chopra says we know next to nothing about the historical Jesus, he does with the presupposition that the text of Scripture is unreliable (as he's already expressed.) Deepak gives us no reason, apart from his feelings, and commitment to his pagan religion.

Deepak's agenda is evident:
One Jesus is historical, and we know next to nothing about him. Another Jesus is the one appropriated by Christianity. He was created by the Church to fulfill its agenda. The third Jesus, the one this book is about, is as yet so unknown that even the most devout Christians don't suspect that he exists...
... the Jesus who taught his followers how to reach God-consciousness. I want to offer the possibility that Jesus was truly, as he proclaimed, a savior. Not the savior, not the one and only Son of God. Rather, Jesus embodied the highest level of enlightenment... Jesus intended to save the world by showing others the path to God-consciousness.

What kind of "savior" is Deepak going to offer us? What will this savior save us from? Notice Deepak's "Jesus" is a powerless man, who is merely "showing others the path" to some "God-consciousness". This is really nothing more than the gnostic heresies revisited in a pagan wrapper. This is not a savior who will save us from the wrath of God (doubtful that Deepak believes in God or that God is wrathful against sin), no this is a savior who will make us more... what? Enlightened? (Imagine the enlightenment Chopra will experience when he stands before the Judge of the universe whom he told lies about.)

Depak's savior cannot save, he can only "point the way", he cannot provide truth, only offer suggestions, he is not the Sovereign Lord of Glory who's coming to judge the quick and the dead, merely another self-sufficient man, like Chopra, worshiping and serving the creation rather than the creator. Chopra molds Jesus into his own image.

Chopra mocks the hope of believers, that their Deliverer is coming, he declares Christ's promise to return as "destructive" to Christ's intentions.
The idea of the Second Coming has been especially destructive to Jesus's intentions, because it postpones what needs to happen now.
Doesn't THIS sound familiar?
2 Peter 2:3-9
Know this first of all, that in the last days mockers will come with their mocking, following after their own lusts, and saying, "Where is the promise of His coming? For ever since the fathers fell asleep, all continues just as it was from the beginning of creation."
For when they maintain this, it escapes their notice that by the word of God the heavens existed long ago and the earth was formed out of water and by water, through which the world at that time was destroyed, being flooded with water.
But by His word the present heavens and earth are being reserved for fire, kept for the day of judgment and destruction of ungodly men. But do not let this one fact escape your notice, beloved, that with the Lord one day is like a thousand years, and a thousand years like one day. The Lord is not slow about His promise, as some count slowness, but is patient toward you, not wishing for any to perish but for all to come to repentance.

Here is Chopra, the ungodly man of whom God's is reserving judgment and wrath for. Chopra is the mocker, the charlatan... a true witch and sorcerer misleading many.

Later, we find Chopra quoting the Bible selectively:
He promises that God loves you, a statement he makes directly, without asking you to follow the duties of your sect or to respect the ancient, complex laws of the prophets. Further, he says that God loves you best. In the world to come, you and your kind will get the richest rewards, everything you have been denied in this world.

The words sound idealistic to the point of lunacy—if God loved you so much, why did he saddle you with cruel Roman conquerors? Why did he allow you to be enslaved and forced to toil until the day you die? The priests in Jerusalem have explained this many times: As the son of Adam, your sins have brought you a wretched existence, full of misery and endless toil. But Jesus doesn't mention sin. He expands God's love to unbelievable lengths. Did you really hear him right?... And yet how beautifully Jesus wove the spell...

Jesus doesn't mention sin? Maybe on Chopra's own little planet, the Jesus of history however is the one who declares "This is the judgment, that the Light has come into the world, and men loved the darkness rather than the Light, for their deeds were evil...", Chopra selectively quotes what appeals to him, but yet he still accuses Christ of evil.

Chopra's "Jesus"teaches non-violence, but cannot save, teaches God-consciousness but is not God, teaches peacefulness without providing the peace that surpasses understanding.

Time hasn't altered this mixture of hope and puzzlement. I had an experience that centers around one of Jesus's most baffling teachings: "Whoever hits you on the cheek, offer him the other also." (Luke 6:29)... Jesus wasn't preaching masochism or martyrdom. He was speaking of a quality of consciousness that is known in Sanskrit as Ahimsa. The word is usually translated as "harmlessness" or "nonviolence," and in modern times it became the watchword of Gandhi's movement of peaceful resistance....Without these conditions, Ahimsa isn't spiritual or even effective. If someone full of desire for retaliation turns the other cheek to someone equally enraged, the only thing that will occur is more violence. Playing the part of a saint won't make a difference. But if a person in God-consciousness turns the other cheek, his enemy will be disarmed.


So Chopra's "Jesus" is only showing the way to pagan non-violence techniques. The reason for non-violence, the rationale for doing unto others, the engine that truly provides this is missing from Chopra's venom. No Spirit, no God, no salvation... no peace.

The Bible's version of peace with others starts with our peace with God, through the sacrificial death of Christ on the cross. We love, because He first loved us. Our peaceful actions towards our neighbors must be rooted in that fact and in the engine, the indwelling Holy Spirit, who graciously conforms us to the image of Christ day-by-day.

So let me provide you, and Chopra with an alternative Jesus, the REAL Jesus of whom the Scriptures clearly declare without contradiction and without pagan interpretation.
Phil 2:3-11
Do nothing from selfishness or empty conceit, but with humility of mind regard one another as more important than yourselves; do not merely look out for your own personal interests, but also for the interests of others. Have this attitude in yourselves which was also in Christ Jesus, who, although He existed in the form of God, did not regard equality with God a thing to be grasped, but emptied Himself, taking the form of a bond-servant, and being made in the likeness of men. Being found in appearance as a man, He humbled Himself by becoming obedient to the point of death, even death on a cross. For this reason also, God highly exalted Him, and bestowed on Him the name which is above every name, so that at the name of Jesus EVERY KNEE WILL BOW, of those who are in heaven and on earth and under the earth, and that every tongue will confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father.

Here is a true Savior, the God-Man who paid my debt to God on the cross that I might be reconciled to God and my fellow man through Him, not because I was able to achieve or find in-and-of myself some "god-consciousness, rather that I was able to find a truly loving Savior, outside of myself, who would graciously save me, not on the basis of works I'd done in righteousness, but on the basis of grace through faith in Him.

Wednesday, March 19, 2008

Remember!





The debt o' blood we paid in blood:
'Remember, boys, the Alamo!'
Fired every Texan where he stood,
An' nerved his arm for deadly blow.
We whipped 'em, lads, an' Liberty
Was born, that day, through fire an' smoke,
This one old comrade's left to me."
He lit his clay pipe as he spoke.

From "Remember the Alamo" by Rose Hartwick Thorpe

(Picture found at preachrblog.blogspot.com)

Tuesday, March 18, 2008

Issues, Etc.



That you might know what is going on with those involved: read this.

Donations to help the families involved can be sent to the following:
St. Paul Lutheran Church
Box 247
Hamel IL 62046.
Just mark it Wilken/Schwarz Fund

Issues Etc Canceled?!


That fantastic Lutheran (LCMS) radio program has apparently been canceled. Details will appear as I get them.

UPDATE - (ht: Fr. Chaz, Fr Weedon and Chrisopher Heren, SSP)

"Today's a black day in the LCMS. Today the Synod ordered the cancellation of the popular radio show Issues, Etc. without stating a reason why, and terminated the employment of Pastor Todd Wilken, the show's host, and Mr. Jeff Schwarz, the show's producer. Folks, I don't know about you, but I do not think we can sit by and let this happen." from http://weedon.blogspot.com/

UPDATE: The Issues Etc Website Has Vanished - the page now reads


"Issues, Etc. is no longer available."

Contact KFUO

Synod: 888-843-5267
KFUO: 314-725-0099

David Strand:
David.Strand@lcms.org

Synod's address:
1333 S. Kirkwood Road
St. Louis, MO 63122-7295

infocenter@lcms.org

Pray for our brothers and sisters in the LCMS as well as the families of Fr. Wilken and all those involved.

UPDATE - There has been some suggestion that a liberal(ish) movement in the LCMS has called for the demolition of hard-line conservative structures within the LCMS. This movement, known as "JesusFirst" (they smell like sheep...). They claim:
"We reject any insistence that the Gospel is best shared through one particular cultural form or tradition..."
"We reject insistence on human traditions or regulations which unnecessarily limit any legitimate use of God's gifts for ministry among pastors and lay people, both men and women."
"We reject practices that unnecessarily raise and maintain walls of separation within the body of Christ."

Sound familiar?


And on another note, the Iron Sharpens Iron radio program is in danger! http://www.wnygspiritofny.com/ has made comments to the host that the program simply doesn't appeal to the house-wife listeners of Christian radio (of course not, the listeners want CCC and "Apostle Charles Jones" sermons.) Please support both of these ministries by contacting their respective radio stations and letting them know that you support both radio programs.


Friday, March 14, 2008

A response to "Christology - Differences Between Calvinists and Lutherans"


A reply to Paleolutheran's Youtube video: Differences between Calvinism & Lutheranism


You start your video stating that "they [Calvinists] start with [God's sovereignty] where as we would start with Christ". I believe this is a false dichotomy common among Lutherans, firstly Christ IS God, always has been God. Christ therefore is sovereign. When Calvinists speak of God, we speak of the Triune God of Scripture. Yes, the three persons of the Trinity have differing roles in the plan and purpose of God, but that plan is a primary focus of Scripture, "namely, that God was in Christ reconciling the world to Himself" and "He predestined us to adoption as sons through Jesus Christ to Himself". Since Paul saw fit to make these points foundational to understanding the mission of Christ, we believe this is important too.

You ask how Scripture can get us "logically from God's Sovereignty to the Cross" and it is apparent thusly: "He chose us in Him before the foundation of the world, that we would be holy and blameless before Him" (Eph 1:4) The Triune Sovereign God's plan was, from before the foundation of the world to save and sanctify a people to reign with His Son through the shedding of His Son's blood and His resurrection from the dead. Without God's Sovereignty, the cross is meaningless, and vice versa. No matter where you "start", you end up at the other.

When you say that the Gospels aren't about God's Sovereignty, you seemingly gut vast sections of the Gospels because of a preconcieved notion. God is love, but God is ALSO just etc. One cannot propose that God is love apart from the fact that God is just (and sovereign.) Let me explain, John 3:16, the most often quoted passage about God's love is surrounded by verses in the immediate context that describe God's justice and sovereignty as well. While it is true that "God so loved the world" it is equally true that "unless one is born again he cannot see the kingdom of God". Also, consider the intensity with which Christ expresses God's complete sovereignty over salvation in John 6:

John 6:37-40 "All that the Father gives Me will come to Me, and the one who comes to Me I will certainly not cast out. For I have come down from heaven, not to do My own will, but the will of Him who sent Me. This is the will of Him who sent Me, that of all that He has given Me I lose nothing, but raise it up on the last day. For this is the will of My Father, that everyone who beholds the Son and believes in Him will have eternal life, and I Myself will raise him up on the last day."

The climax of this is found soon thereafter:

... John 6:44 "No one can come to Me unless the Father who sent Me draws him; and I will raise him up on the last day.
Here is the exhaustive sovereignty of God (and thus Christ) expressed in THE GOSPEL. The Calvinist contends that apart from God's sovereignty, God's love is not rightly understood and vice versa.

You then say "We freely confess that Mary is the mother of God" - Great so do we, do not confuse greater fuzzy-evangelicalism with Reformed theology and/or Calvinism. Just because modern Purpose-Drivel evangelicals shudder when the concept of theotokos is presented, does not mean that Calvinists deny it.

As far as "body and blood", Robert Letham says the following:
Christ does not come down to us in his body and blood. Instead, we are lifted up to him by the Holy Spirit. Christ, being the eternal Son of God, is of course, everywhere. Moreover, he has permanently united himself to the human nature assumed in the incarnation. In that sense, the person of Christ is present with us as we eat and drink. Yet, on earth, the Son of God was not restricted or confined to the humanity he assumed, but was simultaneously filling all things, directing the universe even as (according to the flesh) he walked the dusty roads of Palestine. So, at the right hand of God, the Son fills and directs the universe (Col. 1:15-20), now unbreakably united to his assumed humanity, while in terms of that same humanity he is limited and in one place. Yet that humanity is never separate or apart from the divinity, the eternal Son of God with whom and in whom it is one undivided person. Thus, in the sacrament the Holy Spirit unites the faithful to the person of Christ as they eat and drink the signs, the physical elements of bread and wine. There is an inseparable conjunction of sign and reality. As truly as we eat the bread and drink the wine, so we feed on Christ by faith." (Robert Letham, The Lord's Supper, 28-29).

You state that Calvin (and thus Calvinists) believed that "physical flesh could not contain the divine" and that the "divine nature cannot communicate divine attributes to the physical nature", I ask that you provide a specific citation and context for this claim. If I know the quote you're referring to, Calvin is speaking of our capacity to contain the divine in a sense of understanding, grasping, not that Christ could not be God and man nor that humans could not be indwelt by the Spirit of God. Otherwise, not being an expert on the words of Calvin, I can only suggest that you interact with more scholarly Calvinists on this specific subject before claiming what you have.

But on another note, you state "God can do whatever he wants" in relation to the Eucharistic meal being Christ's physical body and blood. The question is not "what can God do", for as you noted, Calvinists are believers in the sovereignty of God (to an extreme!) and thus willingly accept that God "can" do anything, rather the question is: What DID and DOES God do? Does Scripture support the view that the elements of the Eucharist are transformed into Christ's body and blood, or that Christ's body and blood are in, with and under the elements? Both camps stake their claim on the very same verses wherein Christ says "this is my body" etc. But this language is strikingly similar to where Christ states that "I am the vine" and the like. If you disagree with this, you must explain why, not simply rest upon an ipse dixit.

Why MUST these verses be interpreted as Lutherans do? What grammatical or contextual evidence supports your claim? And what Biblical reason can you present to show that Lutheran view is the correct one whereas the Roman Catholic view is not?

You stated that: "It also comes to pass that many Calvinists... denied that Mary was Theotokos." Can you please tell us which Calvinists specifically? It is evident that Calvin accepted the historical title and what it identified, namely who Christ was, more so than who His mother was. Your usage of this in a video defining the differences between "Calvinists and Lutherans" suggests that you don't know Calvinists nor Calvin very well.

You suggest that Calvinists believe that the "divine aspect of Christ [is] running around... disembodied on Earth", what is your basis for this claim? What Calvinist writings have you read that state such? Calvinists do not believe that the divine nature of Christ is separated from the human nature of Christ, yet is it the Lutheran who believes that Christ's divinity is in heaven and his true flesh and blood here on Earth? Why is the charge not reversible?

You state that "in their [Calvinist] doctrine they have explicitly stated Nestorianism, roughly". Firstly, please provide citations wherein Calvinists state a belief in Nestorianism, secondly please explain how something can be "explicitly stated, roughly".

You then make the claim that Calvinists attempt to rationalize (the supper?) and figure out God's ways. Yet it is not Calvinists who want to say that Christ's body and blood must be "in, with and under" the elements, rather we recognize the Spiritual mystery that is the supper and admit that Christians do feed on Christ really and spiritually, taking true nourishment from the Son of God. Who is rationalizing? Who is really letting the Scripture speak
and rightly dividing the Word of Truth? Herein lies the rub, if one cannot discern a clear difference between the Roman Catholic reasoning for transubstantiation and Lutheran reasoning for their view what difference is there but semantics?

Now, don't get me wrong here, I realize that Lutherans are NOT Roman Catholics on this matter, but it seems odd to me that this video starts out by claiming that Calvinists "start with God's sovereignty" and yet it seems that the video is more about calling Calvinists Nestorian without any actual citations or evidence to that claim only the attempted figuring by supposed Calvinist statements. Paleolutheran doesn't spend much time actually explaining what is wrong with accepting God's Sovereignty simultaneously with God's love and Christ's sacrifice.

(One note here, for Paleolutheran's benefit: One will often hear Calvinists defending God's sovereignty more often than other aspects of God's nature not because that is their primary doctrine, as is often the claim, rather it is because throughout history the opposition to Reformed doctrine has taken a decidedly semi-Pelagian or Pelagian view of the fall and the nature of man. Calvinists are therefore having to defend the sovereignty of God over the supposed "free will" of man from those of a more Arminian and/or Pelagian persuasion.)

Again, you seemingly quote: "the divine nature cannot communicate divine attributes to the physical nature", I again ask for a specific citation and context by which to understand this claim. If, as I suspect, this 'quote' is taken out of context, and in partial, most of the basis for your video falls apart.

Finally, here is what Calvinists actually believe about the supper:

The Lord's supper is a sacrament of the New Testament, wherein, by giving and receiving bread and wine according to the appointment of Jesus Christ, his death is showed forth; and they that worthily communicate feed upon his body and blood, to their spiritual nourishment and growth in grace... (WCF, Larger Catechism, Q.168)

...they that worthily communicate in the sacrament of the Lord's supper, do therein feed upon the body and blood of Christ, not after a corporal and carnal, but in a spiritual manner; yet truly and really, while by faith they receive and apply unto themselves Christ crucified, and all the benefits of his death. (WCF, Larger Catechism, Q.171)

In like manner God hath given us, for the support of the bodily and earthly life, earthly and common bread, which is subservient thereto and is common to all men, even as life itself. But for the support of the spiritual and heavenly life which believers have, He hath sent a living bread, which descended from heaven, namely, Jesus Christ, who nourishes and strengthens the spiritual life of believers when they eat Him, that is to say, when they apply and receive Him by faith in the spirit... n the meantime we err not when we say that what is eaten and drunk by us is the proper and natural body and the proper blood of Christ. But the manner of our partaking of the same is not by the mouth, but by the spirit through faith. Thus, then, though Christ always sits at the right hand of His Father in the heavens, yet doth He not therefore cease to make us partakers of Himself by faith. This feast is a spiritual table, at which Christ communicates Himself with all His benefits to us, and gives us there to enjoy both Himself and the merits of His sufferings and death, nourishing, strengthening, and comforting our poor comfortless souls by the eating of His flesh, quickening and refreshing them by the drinking of His blood. (Article 35 — The Holy Supper of Our Lord Jesus Christ, Belgic Confession)
One final word, I am excited to see Lutherans willing to deal with these issues openly. As I've stated previously, it seems that Lutherans are content to do hit-and-run apologetics, whereby they accuse Calvinists of all sorts of errors and yet neither backup their claims nor respond to their critics. I hope this is not the case here.

Tuesday, February 26, 2008

Having Trouble installing Adobe CS3 Web Premium on Windows Vista 64?



Issues: Install CS3 causes error messages such as:
Adobepdf.dll not found
Adobe Lingusitics Library not installed
Installation Failed

I spent a couple days online trying to solve the problem. Then I called Adobe support at (866) MY-ADOBE, they will support this issue for free, as long as you legit own product. Adobe support is EXCELLENT, even if speaking accented English. Don't give them a hard time. They're fantastic.

The tech had me run the cleaner program available from:
http://www.adobe.com/support/contact/cs3clean.html
You may need an application from Microsoft to get this to work. The cs3 clean should tell you what it is called. This cleans out any remnants from previous install attempts.

Read these dialogs of the cleaner ap carefully, you want to agree to the EULA and do an option #1, don't back up anything etc. Make sure to put in your install directory when it asks.

Once complete, run the cleaner again, this time type 4 at the option prompt, I know there will be no option 4 visible on the options display, but option 4 is a deep clean . Run this cleaner at least 4 times.

Go to start, Run and type msconfig and hit enter.

msconfig
Click the Services tab and turn off all NON MICROSOFT services, click the Start up tab and turn off all startup aps. Reboot.

Run CS3 install.

If install asks for AdobePdf.dll click X on the WINDOWS box asking for it (NOT the Adobe installer).

After CS3 install complete, follow instructions here: http://kb.adobe.com/selfservice/viewContent.do?externalId=kb401731

You will install Windows update KB930627, and then you will need to update Acrobat later. The Windows installer will suggest that you reboot, and you should.

Once you've rebooted, you should be able to register your product and use it normally.

I hope this helps. If you see I missed any steps or have a different issue, feel free to comment.

Thursday, February 14, 2008

British Planes that Didn't Stink

B-57 Canberra
B-57 Canberra

As a follow up to my post about silly British aircraft, I wanted to highlight at least one British plane that didn't stink, and some American failures. The above aircraft is the English Electric Canberra, intended as a high-to-mid altitude bomber, the Canberra caught the attention of the USAF who was, at the time, considering the Martin XB-51.

Martin XB-51
Martin XB-51

The XB-51 had been designed with certain specifications in mind, but by the time of implementation, the needs had changed and the Canberra outperformed the XB-51 in most areas and better fit the role.

The USAF chose the Canberra over the XB-51 and designated it the B-57 Canberra. The Canberra, similar in shape as the famous U2 spy plane, fulfilled multiple roles within the US services including reconnaissance and attack/bombing during the early 1950s.

Martin, the developer of the XB-51 actually picked up the license to build the B-57 and was the US source for the plane.

The B-57 Canberra is still in use by NASA as a high-altitude research aircraft designated as the WB-57, NASA's two aircraft are the only ones still flying in the world today.

Wednesday, February 13, 2008

Tele-communi-cations

(Title from the song by Flock of Seagulls [or was it flock of haircuts?])

My wife and I recently had a thirteen year old girl visit us and had chance to consider this modern age we live in. I'm 36, but I suddenly feel like my parents saying, "When I was a kid, I had to wait all day to find out if my friend was home!!! AND WE LIKED IT!"

I've often considered the impact the cell phone has had on our society. But this really brought other aspects home.

Firstly, I believe that lacking in this gotta-have-it-now world is true communication and even more, thought and consideration. In the spate of a couple hours this young girl made up with a "boyfriend" (consider she was recently "in love" with a different guy), found out that he was "seeing" someone else, dumped him and was considering another boy for romance. All this from a bunch of high-speed text messages sent over a cell phone. I then considered just how often my wife and I have miscommunicated through that same medium and other instant-communication methods. (Not even considering the potential danger one is in when texting on the road, bathroom, movie theater, or the line at Starbucks... YES Miss-triple-carmel-mocha-with-a-squirt-of-peppermint I'm talking about YOU.)

With all these ways and devices to communicate instantly, continuously and throughly, there's very little actual communication going on. These devices seem only to means to display our own narcissistic tendencies and talk about ourselves to anyone who'll listen. (Can you say BLOG!? Yes, I recognize the irony...)

I tried to express this thought to the girl, but of course she didn't hear what I was saying cause she was texting some poor fool "i <3 u".

Secondly, ever notice how blog comments can often turn into wars? People seem to be filled with bravado behind a keyboard. The same girl was recently the target of some very nasty messages on Myspace. People who probably wouldn't have the guts in person can say just about anything in the semi-anonymity of the blog-youtube-text-o-sphere. These means and devices are yet only props for us to display our further depravity. This brings me to my final observation.

Perhaps most importantly, these things cause us to lose sight of what's really important. Time. Apart from the just general waste of time texting silly messages to people you barely know and the like, there's the whole issue of not being able to think about what one says before you hit SEND. Not 20 years ago you couldn't be bothered on the road with the incessant blaring of your previously-favorite-song demanding that you answer the call from the person who you really don't need to talk to while changing lanes. (Have you ever noticed how hard it is NOT to answer?)

Time. To think about what is going on before responding. When my wife and I argue, often the only thing that enables us to work it out is simply the passage of time in which one is able to think the issues over. With these instant-communication devices, there doesn't need to be time to think, in fact, these things demand instant decisions!

Time. At thirteen years old the concepts of romantic love, truth, value, importance, and even danger are skewed and not fully formed. It never occurs to these kids that saying things in a text message, or Internet post can get serious trouble... and even if and when it does the depth of the trouble isn't apparent to them. Consider that the TV show "To Catch a Predator" is on all the time... so many people looking to satisfy their basest urges with all these instant-messaging children.

I got my first computer at 14 and began using BBS systems almost immediately. It never occurred to me then that there might be people looking to take advantage of me, and perhaps with the instantaneous and widespread nature of today's communication its much easier to find victims and take advantage of them.

I don't know what the solutions are, or where this is all headed, however, I note that for now that the direction is negative and it seems these things are yet one more means for the world to infiltrate the forming minds of children and fool them into thinking they're somehow grown ups.

I'd like to hear your thoughts on this stuff. Please comment.

Monday, February 11, 2008

Monday, February 4, 2008

British Aircraft... just an observation


In keeping with the title of this blog, I have an observation:

I love to read books about aircraft history. I've noticed, however, that those written by Brits always highlight the British aircraft (go figure) and each section usually ends something like "... but the programme was in the end, a failure, as the American plane was more robust, more economical and actually arrived during the right decade." occasionally followed by, "... but the plane did find some success in the Empire's armed forces which spend an unbelievable sum keeping them in flight to this very day."

Pictured above is the Hawker Siddeley Nimrod, a most... unique... looking aircraft that handles maritime patrol duties for the UK. The Nimrod was based on the de Havilland Comet, a plane with an infamous past. Now sure, the US has lots of planes (B-52 anyone) that have been updated etc. for ages, the B-52 is a classic example. But in the history of flight it seems that the UK has had more than its share of crazy machines.




The Bristol Brabazon was a beast of a plane, nearly the size of a modern 747 but able to carry only 100 passengers... you do the math. First prototype was built in 1949, by 1953 it was obvious the bird was a loser and the project was canceled. Fortunately, this is one plane that didn't end up in the military ranks.

-- Update --
Someone in #pros mentioned all the pre-(and during)-WWII British planes that were successful, and I admit the Brits had some great aircraft. However, post-WWII there are very few notable examples. Regardless, my point is that Britain seems to have more than its fair share.

Alpha & Omega Ministries Website

The site is up. After a lot of work and much hair-pulling, the A&O site went live about a week ago. I'm really happy with it, and hope it makes getting information easier as well as provides a better spring board for Dr White's ministry.

Tuesday, December 4, 2007

Sola Fide Store


Visitors to my blog might find some of the items at this store of interest, if you can think of any items you'd LIKE to see there, let me know.

You might also like the designs at this store. Lots of great stuff there.

Monday, December 3, 2007

Another Sermon by Chaz Lehmann


Chaz is at it again, he's written another Sermon and posted it here.

It's actually really good.

In fact, his topic brings up something I've been wanting to mention for a while. I recently read Peter Leithart's book, A Son to Me: An Exposition of 1 & 2 Samuel, it deals with some of the same material Chaz' sermon is about. I really enjoyed it and highly recommend it. I realize, of course, that Leithart is one of those "FV" types, but I really think there's a lot of good stuff in this book.

Monday, November 26, 2007

Calvinism, Arminianism, pots and kettles.

The blog entry here identifies John Piper as a "hyper-Calvinist" and in the combox, one poster writes:"I am a little amazed that this Calvinist-Armenian thing is still such a big deal..."

Perhaps these are perfect examples of why Calvinists are so zealous for what they believe.

When I "converted" to the Reformed faith, it was from a sloppy evangelicalism that taught me that all I needed to conquer sin was to pull myself up by my bootstraps.

I'd never once heard a sermon on justification, but I'd heard more than I could count on the "How tos": how to have a good marriage, how to have a better life, etc. Never did I hear the term "predestination" even uttered in any context. No one ever bothered to explain to me that the faith I held had any connection to the historical church. As a result I was powerless to overcome my personal sins, unable to keep the 10 Commandments much less the other 268 how-tos... and had no idea where to turn.

It wasn't until one Bible study teacher bothered to actually read through and explain the book of Romans (the WHOLE BOOK! IMAGINE THAT!) that the ramifications of God's Word, History and God's Sovereignty began to make sense. No longer was I left to my own devices to try harder, believe harder, etc, but I was finally aware that I was saved for a purpose, saved by a perfect Savior who actually got what He desired, and saved from the wrath of God and not some equally powerful devil character. This knowledge has had a profound impact on my life and has caused me to be ever more zealous to read God's Word, preach the Gospel and, yes... talk about the doctrines of grace.

While I initially imagined that the label "Calvinist" or "Reformed" placed me into a unified group that had all the answers, I soon came to realize that the terms were headings for one set of primary beliefs, the adherents of which may have any number of secondary and tertiary differences on such things as infant baptism, 6-day creation, Sabbatarian celebration and others.
What also surprised me was the vehement antagonism of those who did not hold to the Reformed distinctive (namely the doctrines of grace). The very mention of "predestination" set many a non-Reformed person on a diatribe against "errors of Calvinism", more often than not based on complete charactictures of what Calvinists actually believed. The more often I encountered such people the more jaded toward general evangelicalism and evangelicals I became.

Yes, I became a cage-stage Calvinist. The odd fellow, Imonk accurately identifies cage-stage as:
A lot of new and ignorant Calvinists need to...well, shut up. I know that isn't the politest phrase in the book, but it is the truth. Most of the damage done in these matters is done by people who are in what Calvinists call the "cage phase," those inaugural few months when you know very little except some version of TULIP and you won't be quiet about that. These are people who need to get a very large stack of books and get some roots going, but instead they go and pick a fight with whoever is least likely to understand what they are talking about. These converts- often impressionable students or very unread laity- can be obnoxious, immature and thoughtless in their assaults. They've done a lot of damage and there is no apologizing for them. I would say they should be recognized for what they are- untaught, ignorant, and often, young. Most them will grow out of it. A few remain that way until their next phase.

I like to think that I was only "cage-stage" for a short while... but the reality is that I argued obnoxiously with many folks including several acrimonious discussions with my charismatic parents. It took some time to recognize that the doctrines of grace are not only definitional of some Biblical concepts, but actually are true. What I mean is this... one could summary the anthropological content of the doctrines of grace thusly: man is unable to believe the truth unless God causes him to.

What this means for the cage-stage Calvinist is that when they argue obnoxiously and offensively, they're actually doing so in opposition to what they believe! While it is true that the Gospel is offensive to those who are perishing, the message should be the offense, not the messenger and this is often not the case and those who are in this 'stage' need to be counseled by their fellow believers on humility and the nature of the grace that saved them.

All that said, there remains a Biblical warrant for energetic, even aggressive debate, discussion and defense of Biblical truths. Thus when a Calvinist reads the words of people who improperly attribute "hyper-Calvinism" to the likes of John Piper, or misspell Arminian as Armenian (not even close folks), we recognize that the individuals writing in opposition to Calvinists, the doctrines of grace and the Reformed faith in general do so out of ignorance. There is a righteous indignation that arises when one "talks out of their rear", pardon the image. It is akin to the attitude a doctor should have when they hear a layman trying to give goofy medical advice to the dying.

Calvinists believe that the doctrines of grace are part-and-parcel of the Gospel. No we do not believe that every Christian needs to have a complete theological understanding of the nature of justification to be saved, however, we do believe that the truths about the nature of God, man and sin are of the utmost importance and certainly worth fighting over. For it is historical fact that when such distinctives are considered tertiary issues the very fabric of the Gospel is lost.

Without a proper understanding of the nature of fallen man, preaching the Gospel becomes a matter of appealing to the "free will" of sinful men and their "felt needs". Such a view leads directly to the abuses seen in tele-evangelism, Purpose Driven Life-type drivel and the ever popular "Your Best Life Now" kind of trash.

Without a proper understanding of election, much of Scripture becomes a contradictory mishmash of incoherent thought full of supposed "paradoxes". This leaves a convert's new faith open to attack by cults, and other religions. It also leaves room for the individual to view their works as meritorious, redefining grace as merely helpful not essential.

Without a proper understanding of the atonement, its Scriptural basis in God's judicial system and the realities of its saving properties to all for whom it was made for, the nature of sin and its deadly realities can be lost, with universalism being the result. There is truly no consistent theological position between universal atonement and universalism.

Without a proper understanding of grace, one's coming to Christ is left to the individual's ability to understand or reason, again leading to a "sloppy agape" which attempts to woo unbelievers with unBiblical reasoning and methods.

Without a proper understanding of the Christian's perseverance in Christ by grace one could easily fall into legalistic works-salvation efforts or even antinomian "free grace" debauchery.

It should therefore be apparent why Calvinists feel so strongly about the doctrines of grace. They express in shorthand a whole Biblical framework of understanding what John calls "sin and righteousness and judgment", that which Christ came to convict the world of.

Let it be noted, however, that most Calvinists aren't really in this for the argument's sake, rather, we're hoping to provide the same relief we've found to the many questions left unanswered by typical evangelicalism, we want to get beyond the neo-legalism of the "How to" type sermonettes, and we hope that others might become as intrested in God's Word and the history of God's people as we are that they might realize the fantastic plan of God in saving for Himself a people destined to reign in eternity with His Son. We desperately want those who reject the doctrines of grace to engage with us in discussion and debate honestly and with humility. However, more often than not, the kind of response we get are the kinds of canned spin seen from the likes of Dave Hunt, Ergun Caner and Norman Geisler.

In fact, while those who reject the Reformed beliefs clamor about the angry ardor of Calvinists, we generally find dishonesty, guile and downright unloving conduct on the part of non-Calvinists. When we plead with non-Calvinists to discuss the issues in a moderated open fashion, the non-Calvinists engage in deception and trickery to avoid debate and even dealing with the issues at all. On the whole I have found the attitude of non-Calvinists, both online and in churches to be downright sinful in response to our requests for discussion. I've seen non-Calvinist elders lie to avoid direct confrontation and members encourage rebellion in churches that had begun to teach Reformed distinctives.

So drop the "Calvinists are mean, nasty and out to get us" kind of recycled-potted-meat and let's get down to discussing what we really believe. Leave the rhetoric and vitriol at home, and humbly submit your concerns about Calvinism to the Calvinists and pray that God reveal His truth, through His word, to both parties. But be prepared to back up what you say with sound reasoning and the Word of God.

Philippians 1:7
For it is only right for me to feel this way about you all, because I have you in my heart, since both in my imprisonment and in the defense and confirmation of the gospel, you all are partakers of grace with me.

1 Peter 3:15
but sanctify Christ as Lord in your hearts, always being ready to make a defense to everyone who asks you to give an account for the hope that is in you, yet with gentleness and reverence;

Sunday, November 25, 2007

Beowulf ain't bad, but as for the other movie... I hope you MIST it.

I'm visiting my pastor friend down in Southern California. He's also my movie buddy, and we try to see movies that our wives wouldn't dare see with us. Tonight's choices were Beowulf and The Mist.

The good news: Beowulf was pretty good, however, if you go to see it, make sure you find it in 3D, so much of the film seemed intended for the 3D effects, it's hard to imagine seeing it in standard cinema. The computer generated characters are a bit... lifeless at times, but ultimately the story kept our interest. There's some nudity, the computer generated Angelina Jolie is nearly fully nude, however she's truly minus the naughty bits. Also in regards to nudity, there's some unintentional silliness where Beowulf fights Grendel in the buff... the filmmakers placed some strategic objects blocking out his equipment ala Austin Powers. They mention Christianity in the film, negatively, also later in the film it seems the unlikeable 'priests' convert to Christian symbolism. Ultimately the film's story is a bit lacking in moral depth, but it's a pretty good tale.

The very bad news: Steven King's: The Mist is an awful travesty of a film. Perhaps I've forgotten much of the story, since I read it over 20 years ago, but I don't remember the ending being quite so horrendous. There's a 'Christian' character in the film, however, she's a stark raving lunatic charismatic-fundamentalist-freak with delusions of prophetic gifts. The more they played up her insanity (and the resultant following she amassed) the more uncomfortable we became simply sitting in the theater. I don't recall her character in the book, but something tells me that it was probably just like that. The effects are good, the horror and shock wasn't too bad, but ultimately the movie was depressing both in content and in the fact that we felt like we'd wasted $20. Suffice it to say, if you liked the kind of characters, story and ending of Scorsese films (NOT saying this is Scorsese quality, even though I HATE Scorsesi's work) you'll like the blunt ending of this film. I hated it, period.

Fortunately my pal enjoys puns and humor... we spent the rest of the evening making up "mist" jokes. So forgive me if you mist the blog title's joke. Perhaps something was amist in the translation... of course we felt the director's good sense was misting in action. Paying to see that move was a mistake. ;)

Let me know what recent films you might suggest.

Friday, November 9, 2007

Lutherans, Assurance, and Calvinism - a Sermon Review

Before I launch into a reply of Chaz Lehman’s sermon, I want to ask Chaz if he’s really taken a hard look at Calvinism’s exegetical responses to his views. Much of Chaz’s disagreements with Calvinism are nearly identical to those claimed by Non-Lutheran evangelicals, thus I apply the traditional Calvinist replies to his claims.

However, Lutheranism differs in its critique of Calvinism specifically its understanding of assurance. As expressed in the Internet discussions with Pr. McCain of 1/2006, the Lutheran understanding of assurance never points the uneasy believer to evidences (good works, faith, etc.) in their life, but always back to the cross and the sacraments that express Christ’s accomplishments on the sinner’s behalf. Lutheranism rightly acknowledges that man has salvation NO PART in his salvation (apart from God’s grace gift of faith), Lutherans are therefore also rightly concerned about false-pietism and legalism which views righteousness as something inherent in the person and somehow meritorious.

The LCMS website states the following:

Lutherans believe that faith is created and strengthened not by looking inside of one's self (to one's own faith and/or doubts) but by looking outside of one's self (to God's Word and promises in Christ). Therefore, assurance of salvation is to be sought by looking to God's Word and promises in Christ (which create and strengthen the faith through which one is saved), not by looking inward at the strength or weakness of one's own faith (which creates either pride and false assurance or doubt and lack of assurance). (http://www.lcms.org/ pages/internal.asp?NavID=2650)


However, this philosophical position can be taken too far, as is done in so-called ‘free-grace’ evangelical churches, usually of dispensational viewpoint wherein ‘calling upon the name of the Lord’ saves you no matter what you do, or don’t do in the future. There are severe differences between said churches and Lutheran doctrine, so I will not belabor the point.

This often causes Lutherans to be lumped with those who have been rightfully applied the title of antinomian, yet Lutherans do believe that good works are part of a Christian’s life.

The LCMS website also states the following:

The faith of which Paul speaks, of course, is a living faith in Jesus Christ that produces, by God's Spirit, the good works that God wills be done in the Christian's life. That is why, immediately after his beautiful summary of the Gospel in Ephesians 2:8-9, he continues, "For we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus for good works, which God prepared beforehand that we should walk in them." Of this living faith, Luther so eloquently said: "Oh faith is a living, busy, active, mighty thing, so that it is impossible for it not to be constantly doing what is good. Likewise, faith does not ask if good works are to be done, but before one can ask, faith has already done them and is constantly active" (Formula of Concord, SD, IV, 10-11). This is precisely what the entire book of James is all about. Genuine faith is a faith that shows itself in good works. Or as Luther again put it once, as an apple tree makes fruit and the fruit does not make an apple tree, so works do not make a Christian, but a Christian does good works. (http://www.lcms.org/pages/internal.asp?NavID=5561)

So Lutherans DO believe that true faith produces good works. Lutherans do not believe that these good works can ever be evidences of one’s salvation. My concern here is that it seems in direct opposition to every Biblical passage dealing with assurance. Certainly one cannot expect their good works to earn themselves a place in heaven, however, they can expect that if they’re truly a believer in Christ, the fruit of the Spirit will be present in their life, and a lack thereof surely is a sign that something is wrong. I will present this case later.

It is difficult in such discussions to not become argumentative or even haughty about what one believes. It is especially difficult in this case, as it seems that the Calvinist replies to typical Arminian (and in this case Lutheran) arguments against the exhaustive sovereignty of the Triune God go unheard by someone who has spent many hours hanging about in a particular Calvinist chat room and conversing with Calvinists. If one wishes to address a subject like Calvinism honestly, they should attempt to deal not only with what Calvinists believe, but their replies to common objections.

Finally, I must say that Lutheran exegesis, hermeneutics and simple use of Scriptures leave much to be desired. Often verses that speak nothing of the subject in question are appealed to in an offhand manner, suggesting that they’re denied by the Calvinist. Father Charles does this with Paul’s oft repeated greeting “Grace and peace to you…”. I’ve noticed that when I present specific Biblical objections to these arguments to Lutherans, they often seem ignorant of the passages in particular, or have no response at all to them. One Lutheran pastor for example really hadn’t studied Romans 9 at all and was unable to provide a Lutheran commentary on 1 John 2. It seems that Lutheran understanding of any specific Scriptural passage is reliant first and foremost on wearing a specific set of philosophical glasses and if the passage seems contrary to the tint of the lenses, one must reinterpret the passage to blend.

1 John 2 seems of particular difficulty for Lutherans to understand since John seems to go out of his way to make it very very clear that one can “know that we have come to know him if we keep his commands”. Regardless of what “keep” means, the fact of the matter here is that John IS addressing assurance and its relationship to the commands of God.

Sure, Lutherans can say the same of Calvinists with 1 John 1:2, 1 Tim 2:4 etc., however the Calvinist replies to those claims go unanswered by Lutherans.

In spite of the good will shown on such programs as The White Horse Inn and in magazines such as Modern Reformation, Lutherans seem willing to slander Calvinists and ignore their replies.

So it is with a heavy heart and this background information in mind that I take on Chaz’s sermon:


I’m glad I’m not a Calvinist. If I approached the teaching of divine election in the way that Calvinists do, I wouldn’t be able to comfort you. I wouldn’t be able to speak Christ’s word of salvation to you in a tangible way. I would have no choice but to point you to yourself, to your own deeds and your own so-called faith. You would have to look to the holiness of your life for evidences that God had elected you.

It is questionable what one’s view of assurance has to do with the doctrine of divine election, I believe at least on this one point we agree: Those whom God elects to salvation will be saved, regardless of where they look for assurance.

But, to that end, what a boastful statement, "I'm glad I'm not like them!!" Aren't these the words of the Pharisee? 'I'm glad I'm not like THAT GUY, he's not perfect... like me.'

Yet it seems that Lutherans simply ignore great swaths of Scripture because it is difficult to understand, or it ‘peers too much into the mind of God’. If I approached the teaching of Scripture the way Lutherans do, I’d have to rip 1 John, Romans 9, Jude 1 and other passages from my Bible as I could not actually accept what the words therein state.

“We know that we have come to know him if we keep his commands.”

SURELY NOT! For we teach that that no one ACTUALLY OBEYS! No, the source of assurance cannot be one’s own obedience (even if it is by faith alone, in Christ alone, etc…)

1 John 2:3-6
By this we know that we have come to know Him, if we keep His commandments. The one who says, "I have come to know Him," and does not keep His commandments, is a liar, and the truth is not in him; but whoever keeps His word, in him the love of God has truly been perfected By this we know that we are in Him: the one who says he abides in Him ought himself to walk in the same manner as He walked.

How does the Apostle John tell us that we can KNOW that we know Christ? How does the Apostle John tell us that we can know if we are IN Christ? This is not about HOW you’re saved, but how you know that you are in Christ, and the Apostle John points to the evidences of the fruit of the Spirit in one’s life.

“Oh, but that’s John!” You cry, yes but what does Paul say!?

Gal 5:7,22-26 You were running a good race. Who cut in on you and kept you from obeying the truth?...

But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness and self-control. Against such things there is no law. Those who belong to Christ Jesus have crucified the sinful nature with its passions and desires. Since we live by the Spirit, let us keep in step with the Spirit. Let us not become conceited, provoking and envying each other.

Oh that evil pietistic Paul...

Chaz continues:

Jesus dying on the cross for you would be a possibility, but not a certainty.

Actually, it is the Calvinist who can say that Christ died, certainly, for someone, His death ACTUALLY accomplishing what He intended for it to do. Christ’s death doesn’t make us savable, it actually saves!

Whether the Lord bothered to save you would be a question up for debate. Saying that the work of the cross was “sufficient for all but effective for some” really doesn’t get you very far. Where it does get you is fear and uncertainty. But the Word of God is clear. He has died for you. He has forgiven all of your sin.

Limited Atonement (or particular redemption, however you want to say it) is a difficult concept, not because the Bible doesn’t teach it, but because evangelical-dom has so thoroughly saturated preaching with the “all” mentality that what Christ, the Bible and specifically the types and shadows of the Old Testament actually say about atonement and its extent has gotten lost.

The fact of the matter is that, in the end, both Calvinists and Arminians (and in this case even Lutherans) limit atonement. Calvinists limit atonement to those who Christ determined to save and who would actually be saved. That is, Christ actually satisfied the wrath of God on the cross for those whom God intended to save. Christ did not make men saveable, He saved those for whom His blood was spilt in accordance with the intention of the Trinity established throughout the Old and New Testaments whereby God planned to redeem a people for Himself.

The payment wasn't potential, it wasn't partial and it wasn't possible, it was accomplished. Not only did Christ actually pay for sins but he truly was a substitute for those whom He would redeem. Finally, Christ does in fact intercede on behalf of everyone for whom He died (Rom. 8:34, Heb 7:25) ensuring them to the end.

So the Lutheran position is that Christ died for you, has forgiven all your sin EXCEPT the sin of not believing in Him? How comforting is that? The Calvinist can say that IF CHRIST DIED FOR YOU, YOUR SALVATION IS SURE! Where’s the Lutheran’s boasting in his doctrine now?

Paul tells us that “All have sinned and fall short of the glory of God.” But he adds a wonderful word, one word in Greek, two in English… “being justified.” Who is being justified? All, the very same all who have sinned. You, me, and every person who has been born or ever will be born.

As I’ve argued elsewhere this is the claim of the Universalist. To avoid this the Lutheran here has to create a theological construct, called ‘objective justification’ which in reality means “Christ’s death is only efficacious for you if you believe”. While it sounds impressive, it is really no different than the Arminian argument and is subject to the same flaws. Ultimately, in the Lutheran system, Christ only died for some of your sins or can only save you from some of your sins, unbelief is not one of them however.

And so, with Paul, I can say to you, “Grace and peace to you from God our Father and the Lord Jesus Christ.”

Paul writes at the beginning of a letter (TO CHURCHES OF BELIEVERS), “Grace and peace…” but to unbelievers He says, "…God is now declaring to men that all people everywhere should repent…” (Acts 17:30). Calvinists accept that God uses means to save, the Word of God preached is, by the power of the Spirit, to save those whose ears have been opened to it. Surely they teach how to read CONTEXT in Lutheran seminaries?

A Calvinist can’t say that. Not honestly. A Calvinist doesn’t know whether God wants grace and peace for you or not. They have forced themselves to live in a world of uncertainty and despair.

Calvinists can truly say that God desires “grace and peace” to His church, however, if one wants to rip the text from its context, Calvinists aren’t willing to go there.

Consider for a moment that Lutherans believe one can lose their salvation; that is that Christ actually can FAIL TO SAVE those the Father gave to Him! Where is the ‘grace and peace’ now? Lutherans seem to believe that God really wants to save people, but can’t.

Compare that with John 6 “…all that the Father gives me will come to me, and whoever comes to me I will never drive away. 38For I have come down from heaven not to do my will but to do the will of him who sent me. 39And this is the will of him who sent me, that I shall lose none of all that he has given me, but raise them up at the last day.”

The Calvinist can say that they’re quite certain that Christ will lose NONE of those given to Him by the Father.

There’s only one way they could mimic Paul’s words. Grace and peace to some of you from God our Father and the Lord Jesus Christ. The rest of you are going to hell. So where are you headed? In Calvinism, the Gospel is only for those elected to salvation. You can’t proclaim it to anyone else, because it doesn’t apply to them.

Proclaiming the Gospel, the remedy for the Law and the wrath of God that follows it, is what actually brings people to Christ. Paul tells us in the Romans that “faith comes by hearing”, that is, God uses the preaching of the Gospel to actually generate faith by the working of the Spirit. We are commanded then, to preach the Gospel to all mankind that they might hear it and believe and be saved.

Calvinists do no know who the elect of God are, nor do they claim to. We preach to all that if God wishes, all might be saved.

But the Gospel proclamation cannot be made apart from the warnings of the Law. Do not Lutherans even teach that one must BELIEVE in Christ for the effects of Christ’s work on the cross to actually save them from hell? Surely “God loves you and has a wonderful plan for your life” is NOT the Gospel? When Paul preached to unbelievers what did he preach? Should we imitate him, as he told Timothy to do? Paul told unbelievers that “…God is now declaring to men that all people everywhere should repent…”. His message was not “all your sins are forgiven”, but a dire warning of the wrath of God… yes the Law. Paul preached the Law to unbelievers and then showed them the reprieve and mercy found in the Gospel.

We see that, in the parable of the Pharisee and the Publican, that God forgives those with repentant hearts. But the Lutheran here wants to tell them both that they’re forgiven.

Ultimately, Chaz is dishonest here, suggesting that Calvinists only preach to ‘the elect.’ Surely we’re not to bear false witness against one another?

In Calvin’s Strasbourg Catechism, a child was able to say that he was a Christian in fact as well as in name because he could say, “I am baptized in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit.” Unfortunately, modern Calvinists have lost the ability to make their stand on God’s promises. Calvin’s views on predestination have displaced the Gospel entirely. Today’s Calvinists cannot point you to your baptism, because it is entirely useless to you if Jesus didn’t die for you and you have been elected to hell. A Calvinist cannot point you to Christ’s promises, because if you are a vessel of destruction, Jesus didn’t make those promises to you. A Calvinist cannot point you to the Lord’s Supper and the forgiveness that the Lord gives out there because in his thinking an unbeliever receives only bread and wine.

Surely pointing to the Supper, and pointing to baptism of one who denies God and hates His Son does not promise to him salvation?

Since who Christ did die for and didn’t die for, in the biblical view of things, is invisible to us, what is Chaz trying to say? Because we don’t solely point one to their baptism and their partaking of the supper (both external things that THEY may have done?) we’re not giving them true assurance? Again, where in Scripture are we told, “We know that we have come to know him if we were baptized”?

The Calvinist cannot give true, unconditional comfort because they do not confess a true, unconditional Savior. As much as they might claim that Christ chooses apart from any holiness in you, it’s only the holiness in you that they can you point to in order to see if you’ve been elected to salvation.

What does the BIBLE say about this?


1 John 2:3-6 We know that we have come to know him if we keep his commands. The one who says, "I have come to know Him," and does not keep His commandments, is a liar, and the truth is not in him; By this we know that we are in Him: the one who says he abides in Him ought himself to walk in the same manner as He walked.

Heb 12:14 Pursue peace with all men, and the sanctification without which no one will see the Lord.

Looks like the Bible is painfully clear on this issue saying: “By THIS we know that we are in him…” Obviously only a preexisting commitment to a theological perspective can prevent one from accepting the teaching of Scripture.

The will of God is entirely inscrutable, and so the Calvinist can have no certainty of their salvation apart from looking at their own heart, their own works, their own so-called faith. They don’t have the Lord’s promises, because they deny that the Lord’s promises are for all sinners.

"The will of God is entirely inscrutable"? Is not the will of God, specifically His plan and purpose in Salvation revealed to us in Scripture and ultimately in Christ? Should we not look to Scripture to see what God says about certainty in Salvation rather than relying on a man-created system to bypass His holy word?

Does not the potter have the right to do with clay as He wishes? Is the Lutheran “god” the God of the Bible who actually gets everything He desires and whose plans have been immutable since the foundation of the world? What did God PROMISE to Pharaoh? “I raised you up for this very purpose, that I might display my power in you and that my name might be proclaimed in all the earth.”

And what about the Lutheran, does the Lutheran who believes that Christ can die for you, intercede for you, pay for all your sins and yet STILL FAIL TO SAVE YOU have any understanding of the promises of the Lord?

You know the despair that Calvinists have to abide in.

What despair is this!? Despair that if Christ died for me, has me in His hands, I will certainly be found in Him in eternity? Not on the basis of whether or not I “believed enough” but because He is a gracious Lord and Savior?

You hear Christ’s parable of the sheep and the goats and you think, “Surely I am condemned! I am lost! I have failed to feed the hungry. I have turned away strangers. I have ignored the pleas of the naked. I have forsaken the sick and forgotten the ones in prison. The Lord has given me countless opportunities to serve my neighbor and I have failed at every turn!”
You’re right. You are a lost and condemned creature. You have earned hell and all of the torment that it implies. The Law of this passage bites very deeply. It judges you on the basis of your works, and even worse than that, it lists a set of works that no one has ever accomplished consistently and completely. When you listen to it you hear the echoing silence of your own deeds. Some of you have not done these deeds at all. Some of you have squandered opportunities to do them. Some of you have done them with impure thoughts and selfish motives. You deserve nothing but eternal punishment in the place prepared for the devil and his angels.
But wait a minute… If hell is prepared for the devil and his angels, then how can you be eternally elected to suffer there? Jesus has an outstanding opportunity to confess the eternal election of sinners to hell in Matthew 25 and He passes it up. Clearly Jesus needs to read Calvin’s Institutes again. Clearly when He went to Calvinist Seminary He failed systematics.


Where is John 6? Where is Romans 8 and 9? Where is the REST of what Christ said? Surely He does not contradict Himself!

Is it not true that “Scripture has shut up everyone under sin”, are we not all “children of wrath”? It is as if Chaz doesn’t believe in the fall of man! Sure the eternal fire was prepared for the devil and his angels, but Adam, by sinning against God, thrust himself and all in him into that place as well.

We’re all equally destined for that same place, apart from the grace of Christ. Do Lutherans do something that earns them the special merit badge that enables them to dodge God’s justice?

Is not Christ talking to PEOPLE when he says “Depart from Me, accursed ones, into the eternal fire which has been prepared for the devil and his angels”? What is this, contextless exegesis? Does what the verse actually means and its context have any bearing on how to understand it in Lutheran theology!?

Such is the beauty of our Lord. When given an opportunity to use literary parallelism and teach what some would argue is a very logical doctrine, Jesus says, “No thanks.” He says to the sheep, “Come, you are blessed by my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world.” But the Lord absolutely refuses to speak of hell in that way.


Were not the Pharisees also messengers of Satan? Are not all children of Adam messengers of Satan?

John 8:44
"You are of your father the devil, and you want to do the desires of your father He was a murderer from the beginning, and does not stand in the truth because there is no truth in him Whenever he speaks a lie, he speaks from his own nature, for he is a liar and the father of lies.

Matthew 13:38
and the field is the world; and as for the good seed, these are the sons of the kingdom; and the tares are the sons of the evil one;

2 Peter 3:7
But by His word the present heavens and earth are being reserved for fire, kept for the day of judgment and destruction of ungodly men.

Jude 1: 12
These are the men who are hidden reefs in your love feasts when they feast with you without fear, caring for themselves; clouds without water, carried along by winds; autumn trees without fruit, doubly dead, uprooted; wild waves of the sea, casting up their own shame like foam; wandering stars, for whom the black darkness has been reserved forever.

Romans 9:22
What if God, although willing to demonstrate His wrath and to make His power known, endured with much patience vessels of wrath prepared for destruction?

Chaz however believes:

Hell, beloved, was not prepared for you. Even if you die in unbelief, you will not be suffering for eternity in a place prepared for that purpose.

Maybe Romans 9 is simply missing from Lutheran Bibles?

22What if God, choosing to show his wrath and make his power known, bore with great patience the objects of his wrath—prepared for destruction? 23What if he did this to make the riches of his glory known to the objects of his mercy, whom he prepared in advance for glory— 24even us, whom he also called, not only from the Jews but also from the Gentiles?

Everything God does, glorifies himself. Soli Deo Gloria. Chaz continues:

The Lord takes no pleasure in the death of a sinner but wants the sinner to turn from his evil way and live. Every person in hell is a forgiven sinner for whom Jesus died. They are there only because they rejected the gift He won for them by His death on the cross.

While it is true that God has "no pleasure in the death of anyone who dies," this is why He declares, "Therefore, repent and live."

Two things to keep in mind here, just because a person dies doesn't mean that because God doesn't take pleasure in it that it was completely contrary to His eternal plan and purpose, or that He had no idea it would occur. Rather, everything happens for a purpose and that ultimate purpose is to bring glory to God, just as Romans 9 states, very clearly.

Also, If “every person in hell is a forgiven sinner”, on what legal basis does God condemn them? If they’re FORGIVEN, why are they punished? They “rejected the gift”? What gift does the little blind Ethiopian boy who never hears the Gospel preached, reject?

Also, why did our Lutheran writer “accept the gift” but someone else “rejects” it? What was it about our Lutheran pal that made him more amiable to this “gift”? Maybe he was more spiritual? More holy? More… intelligent? Maybe he was just lucky to be born in a land where the Gospel IS preached in the first place?

And, don’t we all “reject the gift” in some way? Don’t we all fail to believe? How is it that one rejects but another… doesn’t?

The glory of God is seen in the Creator of the Universe hanging dead on a cross. When James and John asked to be seated on Jesus’ right and left in His glory, the Lord answered that it was not for Him to give but was for the ones for whom it had been prepared. James and John thought that glory was some sort of worldly pomp and circumstance. They thought that Christ was going to usher in His kingdom like Caesar riding down the streets of Rome in a triumph parade.
But the glory of God is made perfect in weakness. It is seen most clearly when nails are driven through His hands and feet and a crown of thorns is pressed into his scalp. The glory of God is not the death of a sinner but rather the death of His only begotten Son who bears the sins of the whole world.
Calvinists will argue that if you teach an election to heaven that you must also teach an election to hell. It’s logical. It’s reasonable. But they push it to a point that destroys comfort. They make it impossible for you to be certain of Christ’s work for you. But the satanic consequences of their error shouldn’t surprise us.


No, Calvinists argue that the Bible teaches that some, like Judas and Pharaoh, were according to the plan and purpose of God, who, being sovereign, gets everything He desires, destined to glorify God through their rejection of Christ.

Calvinists argue that the Bible teaches that it “does not, therefore, depend on man's desire or effort, but on God's mercy” and that “God has mercy on whom he wants to have mercy, and he hardens whom he wants to harden.”

Calvinists do not argue on the basis of x + y = z, rather we point to Scripture, (remember Sola Scriptura?) to inform our understanding of things. We do not find “rejecting gifts” and “every person in hell is a forgiven sinner” in Scripture, rather, we find that all those who are sent to hell deserved hell, and all those sent to heaven ALSO deserved hell, but were forgiven, graciously and believed on Christ not out of some innate ability or spark within them, but because God graciously chose to have mercy on them. As Scripture says, “By grace you are saved, through faith…”

It is the one who, seeing Scripture that fails to fit his views and refuses to apply his views to the standard thereof but places his theological framework above the very Word of God they claim to preach who engages in Satanic error. Is it Satanic error to accept the Word of God for what it says or to flee from the truth that Scripture teaches for a man-made theological construct?

By teaching an election to hell the Calvinists speak where the Scriptures are silent. They say a word of God that He has not given them to say.

I believe I’ve shown the contrary, and must ask why Lutherans seem ignorant of Romans 9, Acts 4:27-28, Jude 1:12, 2 Pet 3:7 etc.? Was God so clueless when He created the universe that He had NO IDEA that people would go to hell? No, the Scriptures tell us otherwise.

While Jesus makes the beautiful promise to the sheep that the eternal joy they will receive has been prepared for them since the foundation of the world, He scrupulously avoids speaking of an election to hell.

Do not the Apostles speak on behalf of Christ? Do we not accept that the Scriptures are “God-breathed”? If so, is it not Christ then who is ultimately responsible for Romans 9?

The doctrine of election is a source of joy and comfort for every Christian. You who believe have faith because from before the foundation of the world God chose you for that eternal salvation that even now you enjoy.

If God chose them for eternal salvation, how is it possible for them to fall away? Has God chosen EVERYONE for eternal salvation?

The deeds that Christ has done for you are even now reckoned to you. He has visited the sick with healing. He has clothed the naked with his righteousness. He has given you to drink of His own blood. He has given you to eat of His own body.
When you fail to serve your neighbor, Christ forgives you and provides for the one you neglect. When the Lord looks at you at the last day, He will put you on the side of the sheep because He the Lamb of God has taken away the sin of the world. He has forgiven all sinners from the wood of His cross and you who have faith He has elected you to be His own. He has done it from the foundation of the world.
Rejoice, dear Christian. The salvation in which you hope is sure. There is nothing that can snatch you from your Savior’s hand.
In the Name of the Father and of the + Son and of the Holy Spirit.


Finally, something I actually can say “amen” to… however I have to ask, “You who have faith”? What about those who don’t have faith, aren’t they “elected” as well in the Lutheran scheme? If not, how can the Lutheran avoid the same criticism they apply to Calvinists?

It is imperative that the one who speak in the name of Christ speak truth about his brother and even his enemy. Even more, its important for believers to know what they believe, why, and how it differs from others.

Monday, October 29, 2007

Travel, field trip, and journey blog posts being ripped off!

There's a German blog site that is stealing travel related blog posts basically to capture traffic and to sell pharmaceuticals.

My friend, H.C. Newton had a post lifted by this site. You can read the great original post here, and see the infringing work here, yeah it's in German, so use babelfish to translate it.

You might search this site for your own posts! Send Google a fax to let them know!

Wednesday, May 30, 2007

Google AdWords Ruins My Week


My firm does targeted advertising during specific holiday weekends of the year. We're not as interested in doing broad-blast ads during an entire month, but would rather place the ads to run during a specific holiday weekend.

This past Memorial Day I started our first AdWords campaign, and we started getting great placement and clicks right away. Within a day our impressions dropped substantially, the diagnostic stated that we'd exceeded our budget, which was untrue. I played with the budget
figures and noticed the ads running again.

I did change the text of the ad slightly (and this is apparently where I went wrong, according to Google) to achieve better visibility in the list.

Within a couple of hours our ads had stopped running completely. Again the diagnostic tool stated that we'd exceeded our budget (impossible). I increased the budget numbers exponentially, hoping for something to happen.

AdWords diagnostic then told me that my ads were running, "but only occasionally" but it turns out they were not running at all. We'd had plenty of money in the acct, the budget was fine, but our ads weren't running.

Following the disastrous weekend, spent attempting to make AdWords work, I finally got a hold of someone at Google. (Apparently they take the most important advertising times of the year off) and was told that my ads had gone "under review"... (and that I should run them now! Yeah... good idea. Memorial Day isn't THAT important!)

Nothing in AdWords alerted me to the fact my ads were under review, I received only a false message that I'd exceeded my budget. Doing some research in the AdWords help discussion, I found that this is a common problem. Many people have had the same thing occur.

I cannot calculate the amount of money lost this weekend because our ads failed to run. We'd scaled back our print advertising to run Google AdWords, and it failed to produce and failed to even explain what was wrong. With a $3k+ budget for this weekend alone, we spent only $200, thus both we and Google lost out.

I spent a frustrating weekend attempting to manipulate ads that weren't running with no idea that nothing I could do would make them run (and in fact, might even make them go back "under review".) I saw our competitors ads every time I attempted a search, using multiple machines, various locations, but ours failed to materialize.

Surely Google can make it possible for AdWords to alert the user when their ads have gone under review, rather than lying to them and telling them they'd exceeded their budget. Surely Google can afford to have someone on staff during peak retailer advertising times (Memorial
Day, Fourth of July, etc) to help people like me.

This has proven a most frustrating experience, and I'm certain others are having the same experience, just by doing a search of their help groups. Google must do something.

Tuesday, May 29, 2007

Inside the new house


The New Kitchen


The Grill & Instant Deck...


The loft


The Guest Bedroom


The Computer Room (A work in progress)


The dog... in the loft


The Living Room